Fixing mod abuse

yoyo200900almost 9 years ago

I made a thread mocking Lailai for modding projectmatt and charley, two ex-mods that, on record, abused their mod powers, after he said that his new mod team wouldn’t be more of the same.

Moderator mascot PatrykScezie AKA dzanek, who dedicated years of his life to posting poorly-worded unsolicited opinions in the comments sections of reports for inconsequential red heart games so that the mod team would eventually take pity on him and let him fulfil his life goal of becoming a moderator on epicmafia.com (before being quietly demodded for being incompetent), made his first thought provoking post ever in response to the thread.

His hot take could be summed up like this:

“Despite projectmatt and charley using their mod powers for evil, they have given verdicts to so many reports that their overall contribution has been a good one. Therefore, they should be allowed to be moderators again. Please re-mod me, my life is meaningless without the ability to rule verdicts to reports”.

As it stands, the only motivation that an intelligent person could have for being a moderator on the site is to misuse their powers. Therefore, unfair actions by a functional mod team is inevitable. To keep these actions in check, there should be a system put in place that ensures that each moderator is still having a positive effect on the site.

Here is an example of the type of system that could be implemented:

  • Handle a report: Gain 1 point

  • Have your report overturned: Lose 5 points

  • Intentionally handle a report unfairly (cannot be appealed): Spend 25 points

  • Delete a thread that upsets you: Spend 40 points

  • Delete one of your own vios: Spend 50 points

  • Delete a user: Spend 1000 points

In the new world, the only moderators that people will have the right to complain about are the ones that go below 0 points. Moderators will be unlikely to go below their 0 points limit. This means that no one will ever be able to complain about the moderator team and no one will think about the concept of mod abuse ever again.

Rydiaabout 8 years ago
are you suggesting we give mods currency

why don't you use all that modmoney on deleting your thread, nerd
samanthaabout 8 years ago
mod a random noavi for a day for fun lolz see what happens
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
ban ally
10
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
ban the mods!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

we want freedom
barlcroabout 8 years ago
Want to fix this site? Get rid of mods.
1
yoyo200900about 8 years ago
Bump
yoyo200900over 8 years ago
matt
Am i really the first to tldr
matt
Also people are getting shot at concerts innocently, so to compensate we just complain about a slowly ailing party mafia website
Mattposting at its finest
deleteddeletedalmost 9 years ago
Fixing mod abuse86
yoyo2009001mon 4d+6
I made a thread mocking Lailai for modding projectmatt and charley, two ex-mods that, on record, abused their mod powers, after he said that his new mod team wouldn’t be more of the same.

Moderator mascot PatrykScezie AKA dzanek, who dedicated years of his life to posting poorly-worded unsolicited opinions in the comments sections of reports for inconsequential red heart games so that the mod team would eventually take pity on him and let him fulfil his life goal of becoming a moderator on epicmafia.com (before being quietly demoded for being incompetent), made his first thought provoking post ever in response to the thread.

His hot opinion could be summed up like this:

“Despite projectmatt and charley using their mod powers for evil, they have given verdicts to so many reports that their overall contribution has been a good one. Therefore, they should be allowed to be moderators again. Please re-mod me, my life is meaningless without the ability to rule verdicts to reports”.

As it stands, the only motivation that an intelligent person could have for being a moderator on the site is to misuse their powers. That means that unfair actions by a functional mod team is inevitable. To keep these actions in check, there should be a system put in place that ensures that each moderator is still having a positive effect on the site.

Here is an example of the type of system that could be implemented:

Handle a report: Gain 1 point
Have your report overturned: Lose 5 points
Intentionally handle a report unfairly (cannot be appealed): Spend 25 points
Delete a thread that upsets you: Spend 40 points
Delete one of your own vios: Spend 50 points
Delete a user: Spend 1000 points
In the new world, the only moderators that people will have the right to complain about are the ones that go below 0 points. Mod
Gary1988almost 9 years ago
Mod me! I will no vio everyone except for the people I dislike.
yoyo200900almost 9 years ago
Bump
yoyo200900almost 9 years agoedited
I'm asking for Orienteering (who still hasn't said why he wants to moderate)
deleteddeletedalmost 9 years ago
not true (Liva148)
deleteddeletedalmost 9 years ago
Unfortunately, as per a policy change in mid-2015, anyone with numbers in their main account is ineligible to become moderator. Sorry yoyonumbers.
yoyo200900almost 9 years ago
Bebop
he won't ever be a mod
What criteria do you need to meet to be a mod?
deleteddeletedalmost 9 years ago
You don't fix mod abuse. Mod abuse fixes you. For good.
1
Bebopalmost 9 years ago
he won't ever be a mod
yoyo200900almost 9 years ago
yoyo200900
Orienteering
I will be a mod
Why do you want to be a mod? What's in it for you?
Bebopalmost 9 years ago
Bacde
Report abuse should be a vio
10
Bacdealmost 9 years ago
Report abuse should be a vio
Giga13almost 9 years ago
You should never have more than one Note for the same violation type, if this is happening then the whole concept/idea/reasons behind why the Note became a thing has been lost
Giga13almost 9 years ago
LazyYami
You somewhat prove my point, notes are the same as a 1st violation that doesn't give a suspension.
No they aren't
10
jessalmost 9 years ago
Orienteering
I will be a mod
no
20
yoyo200900almost 9 years ago
Orienteering
I will be a mod
Why do you want to be a mod? What's in it for you?
Germalmost 9 years ago
GuyFawkes85
LazyYami
Arguable that there's no punishment difference between note and no vio.
Because a note is half a vio, basically. But Bebop doesn't know that.

"Note
This isn't a violation per se. It's here so that we can draw attention to reports against users in future. This has no infractions and doesn't count towards the 8 violation limit."

After you get a note, if you do that again, you get a vio. If you get a no vio, you're not said to get a vio for that, even if you do it again.
if someone plays inefficiently and gets reported for GTing, a mod might note that. But that doesn't mean the next time the user plays in an unconventional way, he'll automatically get a vio.
Midalmost 9 years ago
what do the points do