Epicmafia

Back to Off Topic

Unban Arcbell

Renaldo

almost 10 years

But only on TheWhiteBunny.

If he breaks character, permaban.

Hibiki

almost 10 years

first post was a joke, the other quotes are true

justrec

almost 10 years

demod hibiki

deletedalmost 10 years

i mean idc that much, because it's just an /opinion/ and nothing i say, or almost nothing i say will change your opinion although your opinion has changed on what gamethrowing is several times

deletedalmost 10 years

Hibiki says

the criteria's changing, pal

Hibiki says

in all honesty, logically, the doc should be at fault. that might not be the way it was but that's what i want to discuss with ppl.

Hibiki says

well in all honesty, yes, if it's incredibly obvious that the doctor is saving someone even on meteor night, intentionally killing the save is just as bad (but NOT worse) than the doctor's actions.

but it's a terrible precedent to set that the doctor is not at fault themself, and one i want to change

Hibiki

almost 10 years

Devante says

connor is currently advocating sub optimal town play this is amazing lol i wish i could go to the last jan round he trophied in and find a game where he suggested lynching on mylo excluding day 1 cop save.

you don't understand anything i've said ITT

Edark

almost 10 years

fartbell lol!

deletedalmost 10 years

connor is currently advocating sub optimal town play this is amazing lol i wish i could go to the last jan round he trophied in and find a game where he suggested lynching on mylo excluding day 1 cop save.

deletedalmost 10 years

Yeah lol imagine if the townies grew balls and lynched ...

Jaleb

almost 10 years

Hibiki says

Jaleb says

Why do we even put a doc in jan if saving until maf forces meteor is therefore town's fault?

you've jumped like 7 logical setups to get to there and i don't know the steps you've taken so you're going to have to elaborate

the scenario you're suggesting is that the only person the doc should be allowed to save is the player that gets reports (cop). Otherwise you are letting maf hit the same person 4 times with nothing accomplished.

deletedalmost 10 years

bell says

It's mafia's fault, not doc's in that situation. Thus they get the GT for forcing meteor.

Hibiki

almost 10 years

Jaleb says

Why do we even put a doc in jan if saving until maf forces meteor is therefore town's fault?

you've jumped like 7 logical setups to get to there and i don't know the steps you've taken so you're going to have to elaborate

deletedalmost 10 years

harsh

deletedalmost 10 years

Twist says

Devante says

okay you're trolling dude w.e

Words of a loser.

find the nearest bridge, make sure you bring an anchor with you

deletedalmost 10 years

Devante says

okay you're trolling dude w.e

Words of a loser.

Jaleb

almost 10 years

Why do we even put a doc in jan if saving until maf forces meteor is therefore town's fault?

Hibiki

almost 10 years

devante, i am only being logical

deletedalmost 10 years

okay you're trolling dude w.e

deletedalmost 10 years

Hibiki says

remember, in order for meteor night to happen, town must actively choose to NL 3 times

what the actual ... why don't we just give mafia wins in every game, town is at a significant disadvantage already in this meta in jan 2.0 - actually every setup, you're literally right now advocating for bad mafia play to be rewarded

Hibiki

almost 10 years

that is fine, town could have prevented it by lynching on the previous day or picking a better orc choice (not sucking)

deletedalmost 10 years

Bad play bruh.

Jaleb

almost 10 years

The doc was the only player going for the win condition if you pull out the triple nl

deletedalmost 10 years

Connor, let's change the situation. What if the doc was saving the orc the whole time, and on the meteor night the doc didn't go on the orc to not force meteor and the orc was on the doc and revealed the doctor.

Is that fine?

Jaleb

almost 10 years

That's town nling not doc. There is a difference

Hibiki

almost 10 years

Jaleb says

It's also game throwing to let clears die for no good reason. The idea of the game is to not let town die from the attack of the mafia.

if you have a choice between losing a clear and losing the game, losing the clear is not gamethrowing

Jaleb

almost 10 years

Satan says

tl;dr jaleb

Always lynch someone when you have 3 clear with 3 unclear