a gained ML is basically a game-winner, since you gain a clear as well. while statistically your doc save chances are low, being able to read who the mafia will save isn't too difficult (when you know they aren't targetting cop, i mean)
As awesome as getting an extra mislynch is, your chances of doc saving after lynching d1 on a doc save are what, 1/5? Even if you have scumreads on both mafia you're still 1/3, and the mafia might just hit you anyway. Doesn't feel worth the risk to me.
i'd argue that lynching day 1 after a doc save is optimal for town but i wouldn't trust a doctor that isn't me to go off-cop and i can't point that out as a non-doctor without alerting mafia to their chance to kill cop. and i can't do it as actual doctor without outing myself via meta. so NLing day 1 after a doc save/NK is my choice, but in a vacuum, it is sub-optimal
NLing until day 3 gives mafia a chance to kill and remove the chance at a potential 2nd ML.
town are well within the power to prevent the cop kill by meteor by just lynching at MYLO. yes, it's harder than 7 way, but the chance at a gained ML is worth it REGARDLESS of mafia's intent to kill the cop on the next night
playing odd numbers is better for mafia because there are more chances at killing the doctor and zero chance at giving away the ML
you argue: NK 3 nights so that they can kill cop via meteor. i argue: either a) lynch on day 1 and give the doc a chance to gain a mislynch for town, or b) lynch on day 3 before the meteor and do the same, but with 3 reports
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
Hello im here to to ruin the serious conversation with stupid posts
1
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
then make it, because so far you've spouted irrelevant nonsense that still results in mafia's best interest being NKing into meteor
no, i don't really care if you try and kill BV because it's unkillable with the right counter argument
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
At the end of the day, those mafias will get Trolling violations for deliberately antagonizing people via abusing the meteor, and as that bodge suits the vast majority of the site, everything will continue as normal.
a dead blue at LYLO is better than a clear blue at MYLO. they're both confirmed town but the dead blue's report alignment is revealed without the cop needing to check them
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
the argument you're making here is really weird because i think its explicitly grounded in the idea that you dont want me to kill BV
