Round 232 Discussion

deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago

Congratulations to the winners of Round 230!


Zedd

Setups

hollywood illusions

Cry n... oh


flea

Setups

A Framed Drunk Driver

Great And Innovative


dad

Setups

Basic Variant

Anon Jan 2.0 Mario


Good luck to the participants of Round 232!

Giga13almost 12 years ago
xElf
fgm is a fun setup and should stay comped, because after all; we're all here to have some fun.
Play It In Red Heart Or Unranked Not In Competitive Gold Heart
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
Riotkiller
Renaldo
ranked =/= competition

Wasn't it you who blacklisted Classic from Comp?
I blacklisted Classic entirely. I however, was an admin & lobby owner. Not a Mod.




Last time someone told me that, Bear, they were Arcbell.
So if Vancy is telling the mods to take it down and talk to Roshiez about the setup, it shouldn't be an issue then.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
I don't think that there's anything wrong with having FGM comped like once a year. It's been two years since it's been comped. It's not like it plagues the competition or anything.
Simsalmost 12 years ago
what is stickied in comp doesn't apply to main lobby IMO. we're under new management
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Giga13
jackattack123
Anthony
https://epicmafia.com/round/82 there was nothing wrong with this round. also when did turquoise selfdelete?
I find one wrong thing with this round and it is Giga's trophy
The irony is I advocated its decomping for the entire round. But the mods let it stay, and I (along with the other two trophy winners) showed people why it should have been decomped by trophying on it and ruining all of the wonderful other runs that were done on VDLI and legit setups


persuasive argument
Giga13almost 12 years ago
SK vs Mafia shouldn't be comped either imo but it's not as bad
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
fgm is a fun setup and should stay comped, because after all; we're all here to have some fun.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Renaldo
ranked =/= competition

Wasn't it you who blacklisted Classic from Comp?
I blacklisted Classic entirely. I however, was an admin & lobby owner. Not a Mod.




Last time someone told me that, Bear, they were Arcbell.
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
Sims
that's for comp lobby, it isn't stickied in main
I know, so I'm saying that classic, which is allowed in ranked, was made disallowed in Comp Lobby (and thus competition).
Giga13almost 12 years agoedited
jackattack123
Anthony
https://epicmafia.com/round/82 there was nothing wrong with this round. also when did turquoise selfdelete?
I find one wrong thing with this round and it is Giga's trophy
The irony is I advocated its decomping for the entire round. But the mods let it stay, and I (along with the other two trophy winners) showed people why it should have been decomped by trophying on it and ruining all of the wonderful other runs that were done on VDLI and legit setups
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
https://epicmafia.com/topic/60963
Simsalmost 12 years agoedited
that's for comp lobby, it isn't stickied in main
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
ranked =/= competition

Wasn't it you who blacklisted Classic from Comp?
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
Riotkiller
Point Payouts are irrelevant when you have a lower chance of winning, especially when you take into account that they're capped so they're actually on the low-side sometimes if they hit the 120 point cap.

Meta abuse happens every round regardless and party conversions don't do this any more than perfectly legit setups like Sex & Lies

Fool can play Kingmaker rarely. So what? Also, you can quite easily make a rule saying Fool & Lyncher have to play for their higher win condition or else it's gamethrowing.
Sex & Lies conversion doesn't change your win condition like Cult or Yak would.

It's pretty tough to justify giving someone GT for townsiding when they get a win and points for doing so.

Also, there isn't anything written about what's allowed in comp. It was all just mental notes by previous mods, admins and community members.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
riot, you are putting up a vigorous losing fight.
Giga13almost 12 years ago
3rd Parties have no place in Competitive so I'm glad that Manhunt is gone
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Looks like you actually have Rules that disagree with you.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Sims
where in the rules does it state that you're allowed to comp 3rd party setups?
https://epicmafia.com/topic/49090
1
Giga13almost 12 years ago
TheShane
So I can't see round 26 but round 27 is apparently still up?

https://epicmafia.com/round/27
Some rounds can't be viewed. 45 can't be viewed I think because too many of the players selfdeleted or smthn
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
that's nice riot but you're wrong and i'm right lol
1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Point Payouts are irrelevant when you have a lower chance of winning, especially when you take into account that they're capped so they're actually on the low-side sometimes if they hit the 120 point cap.

Meta abuse happens every round regardless and party conversions don't do this any more than perfectly legit setups like Sex & Lies

Fool can play Kingmaker rarely. So what? Also, you can quite easily make a rule saying Fool & Lyncher have to play for their higher win condition or else it's gamethrowing.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
someone please comp jan 2.0 so all the bad setups are in one round
Simsalmost 12 years ago
where in the rules does it state that you're allowed to comp 3rd party setups?
1
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
SK vs. mafia is okay because the payouts aren't as terrible, although the idea of having a 0% chance of achieving your win condition based on the night 1 kill is ridiculously unfair.
TheShanealmost 12 years ago
So I can't see round 26 but round 27 is apparently still up?

https://epicmafia.com/round/27