Mimi is already actress.

Why would Bow be jailer?

Someone else suggested Jolene for agent... but she's really not a huge character.

agent: http://www.mariowiki.com/Jolene
mimic: http://www.mariowiki.com/Mimi
jailer: http://www.mariowiki.com/Bow

woo paper mario :D

agent = jolene from paper mario ttyd

Alternatively, Merlee/Merluvlee for Shrink/Priest
Master for Monk

Bootler for Mortician

+Luigi Watcher
General Guy for Jailer
Merlee/Merluvlee for Priest/Monk
+Twink for Dreamer

Luigi is Mortician 'cause he's the one who deals with Ghosts... could you think of ANYONE else who could be Mort? D:

Hooker should most definitely be Birdo

I agree with Granny Smith - luigi watcher is good for symmetry.

Dreamer could be King Wart maybe? From SMB2. Little known I know.

Also Yoshi jailer might make sense - although bp is good too.

Final suggestion is that you should put petey piranha somewhere. Perhaps jailer or watcher - not sure. This is fantastic btw. I´ll probably return in a bit if I have any more ideas. XD

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/vivian.png

Vivian is Miller. She looks like a bad guy but is a good guy.

Survivor is now Dry Bones. No matter how many times you swat him, he survives.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/drybones.png

Miller - Vivian
Lightkeeper - (Make it Watt not just any Amp)
Shrink - Piccolo(Super Paper Mario, the music could make them not convert due to how magical it is)/Dottie(Just for pun)
Jailer - The Pianta guards from Mario Sunshine(Make the cop be Goombario/Goombella)
Dreamer - Twink(From paper mario, as the wishes could be like dreams)
Blacksmith - Barry
Amnesiac - Shy Guy/Cosmic Spirit
Mimic - Cosmic Spirit(SMG 2)/Shy Guy
Ventriloquist - Shadow Mario(Can change what he looks like to make people think it is him, could also be guiser and Doopliss could be Vent/Mimic)

shy guy = amnesiac
rip van fish = dreamer
survivor = fuzzipede
jailer = bow
miller = vivian

also, make hammer bro judge, toadsworth mason and luigi the watcher (since mario is tracker)

Maybe move Yoshi to Jailer or Blacksmith ((Protecting them by putting them into eggs))

If Blacksmith, make the BP a Yoshi Egg. If Jailer make BP a Rex or something, since they can survive 2 hits in Super Mario World

Rookie from Superstar Saga that is

Amnesiac should be Bowser while he is Popples lackey

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o99NNOV-rAo
1:40, perfect dreamer

...I chuckled. I like it. Will consider :P

make survivor be Dry Bones. :p

http://i.imgur.com/NJgnX.png

Added the bricks into my Epic Mario code. Not gonna do a whole layout since I'm not sure how to do that yet... but I'll do what I can to make it fun for now.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/tubbablubba.png

Tubba Blubba, Werewolf.

Vivian might be Miller. She/he was originally a Shadow Siren, turned good guy.

Vivian wasn't a resident of Twilight town. She was part of the group of Shadow Sirens. I think she should be something better than miller though.

Miller - Shaman
Mimic/Monk - salvo the slime
Agent/Survivor/Hunter - tokotoko
Jailer - Yaridovich
Yo Bro (Idk he might be useful)

Already said it and will say it again: If I start using Enemies for town sided roles, Hammer Bro will be judge. Judge hammers.

:3

STILL NEEDED:
Watcher
Miller
Hunter - albino dino
Agent
Shrink Professor E. Gradd
Jailer
Priest
Monk
Dreamer - Rip van Fish? I can't think of much else.
Blacksmith - Hammer bro
Survivor - Cheepskipper
Amnesiac - Dry Bones
Mimic
Ventriloquist - Petey Phirana