Also, even though Arrogate has a terrible reason to vote me and I love to fos those who vote me for trash reasons, she's a sub-optimal lynch at most.
If I remember correctly, she was supposed to do something last night but didn't do it(?) for whatever reason. But if she does it tonight I believe she can be potentially cleared(?).
Wait, Pinks, I think you slipped, when htennis was here, he wanted me dead we were all pretty sure he tracked me, why didn't you come up with a track report on me?
Oo okay, I missed that lol. I'm assuming goodfrog confirmed her report as well as ghost. Keeping that in mind, she's probably town because she could've hid her report and killed goodfrog at night.
So the way I see it, the only way her actions would make sense as mafia is if goodfrog was mafia with her and she's trying to set up an alibi/clear him. Otherwise I don't understand why she'd out that sorta thing as mafia.
Can you quote the interactions you think indicate Pinks x goodfrog isn't a team? Because if I see what you see, then Pinks is basically confirmed town.
We have two reports already. goodfrog visited me and denial n1, and ghost13 visited no one n2.
Also goodfrog and Pinks 100% can't be mafia together due to the way the interaction about goodfrog's night visits and Pinks' abilities with Birbtales went.
I mean if Birbtales actually let a mafia member with 6 votes on him drop out of the game that's pathetic but yeah it's possible. The way she phrased the first messages seem town to me.
From a quick memory rehash and skim through pages, I believe Pinks claimed to be a delayed(?) tracker? So she checks someone and gets a report on them the next night or something along the lines of that?
For someone like that I think it's best we let her be until she outs a report. If she's real then with the amount of people in this game (and considering we're all prs + mafia), she should get a report asap.
If she keeps turning up blank after several days and uses her delay as an excuse then that's when we should consider questioning her integrity. But for now I think we should just leave her alone.
has it ever occurred to you that pinks is just a better liar? has it occurred to everyone that pinks is mafia and we just let them go thanks to the help of partners taking the fos off her?
I remember the last thing I said here was like, I'll come back and re-read d2 but then I went completely poof for uni commitment. I chose a bad time to join a forum mafia game and ye that's my bad.
But it'll be really terrible for someone else to sub in here and try to understand wth is going on so I won't do that to someone else unlike someone *cough cough* C- *cough cough*.
Also I would not be surprised if it turned out that every single person who has spent considerable effort gamesolving flips town. I can't imagine being mafia and going through that denial/happeh phase while still sounding genuine.
To me, those people were ichaotic, goodfrog, happeh, denial, me, pinks, mw295 if I'm remembering correctly.
edit: possibly ghost13? I will look back later and evaluate this read
I just reread all of day one and day two. I think goodfrog is town. His actions check out, you can see beginning of d2 he comes out strong fosing denial (makes sense that we know he vote blocked him the night before). His posts have town character to them.
It's also funny that I still scumread htennis every single time I go through it. But I townread Pinks' intro each time. I'm pretty sure she is town but I would be so pissed if she flipped mafia and only got away with it because htennis got replaced right before being lynched (not that this game isn't somewhat invalidated already).
I thought I townread Arrogate but going back I really don't. I don't think he is optimal lynch today for all the reasons I have aforementioned. Since I think goodfrog is town, its possible he is mafia with a stalker type skill or even a legit role copy (although that seems like a town ability).
Every confirmed town at this point has scumread Carmen/Spadez. I had a meta tr on Carmen which could be flawed. I think that's someone we have to look at closely.
I have too many people I think are town than can be possible.
Favorite quotes from the game so far: I'm glad spadez thinks I'm clever :)
Game Board