The moderators are forbidding me from comping Classic Mafia (along with other variants such as Fancy Pants) because it is "uncompetitive". While it's on the mods to provide proof that it's uncompetitive, they have not done so, so I would like to start a poll and debate on whether or not this setup is comp worthy.
My vote is "yes". There is a huge skill gap in Classic Mafia. Some Classic players have 40% winrate, while some have 60% or more. You can't say that is all just luck, there is meta mindgames and scumhunting involved, and good report faking is a must.
I don't see what's wrong with comping a (seemingly)one-dimensional setup. There's barely any competition anyway, anyone playing 5 hearts a day consistently for 10 days will end up in the top 10. I talked about this in the deleted thread, every time classic mafia has been comped there have consistently been 25-30+ minute-long games. I'm pretty sure the average a&v game lasts about 20 minutes
