It seems this game has gained a lot of popularity in this lobby, and I want to see what it's like as the host.
All 3 of the games played thus far have ended in evil being victorious. So as per the idea of HighSpace, I will incorporate an extra servant to the game making it 7 good, 4 evil.
This will decrease the chances of placing evil members on missions and increase the Merlin pool for Assassin to shoot in.
6 players are needed to accept or reject any mission
Aigh, so this comment is my read on Ari. Ari leans towards a tr/mass confusion(?) for me.
When I first started reading through the first few pages, they leaned a lil bit more towards the scum side.
[Examples:
Just because someone claimed a pr doesn't mean that they're confirmed inno.
It just seemed like Ari would ask Pod for advice to walk even one step ahead which wasn't really townie to me.]
HOWEVER, considering the fact that Ari cc'ed Perc, now that I look back at what Ari said earlier on, it seemed to me that they were fishing on for reads from their cc to possibly hunt for scum/town.
And as game progressed, the weird/confusing reads that Ari does started happening again aka.
^ Ari did stuff like that prev game too and back then, I thought having inconsistent, seemingly whimsical and contradictory reads was scummy.
I never really understood their confusing reads (now that I think about it, it was prob to hide the Merlin) and Ari just seemed like an overall mess which made me hardcore Sr them.
Turns out, Ari was really perc lol. I was hella shocked and I'm seeing similar behaviour patterns between Ari then and now. That is why they lean towards a tr towards me BUT-
-Ari could be scum, mimicking their prev game antics to seem like the real Perc. And that, is why Ari is also giving me a mass confusion read.
So I'm not sure about whether or not I'd recommend putting Ari on the team.
I'm assuming what thou mean is that thou suspected there to be a fail in the team which came from Jeff. But that makes thy words more suspicious as, if thou thought Jeff was scum, why say with so much confidence the team will pass or why even suggest a team with Jeff of all people?
Unless thou were trying to pressure the hypothetical scum Jeff into passing the mission, thy actions don't make sense.
Stash leans towards an Sr for me. When Stash proposed the team of themself, Jeff and Pod, their statements were really scummy to me.
That sort of confidence shows to me that Stash 100% trusted Jeff and Pod to pass the mission. I'd somewhat understand why Stash would expect a pass from the perc claim, but there's no reason to say with such confidence that the mission would pass without even having enough reads back then on Jeff.
This lead me to one conclusion that Stash knew who scum was, knowing how many would pass. Although Merlin knows scum, they don't know who Mordred so I don't really see Stash softing as Merlin so early on (which would help Assassin) because Jeff/Pod could've be Mordred. Meaning, Stash knew that if there was a hypothetical fail, it'd be from themself only which is why they were so confident in the team passing.
However, their later statement made me come up with another conclusion:
That's a clear message to another member, telling them to pass the mission. Meaning Stash purposefully put another scum (or maybe all 3 were scum but I genuinely doubt that Mafia would do something so suicidal) on team to make both of them seem clear.
Now I know that one may argue; the message seemed to be too obvious to be scummy however, when Stash said this:
They clearly are proving my point in my second conclusion.
The evil peeps can willingly send in passes to seem inno and yet, Stash acted like they were confirmed clear which bugged me.
Stash's reads later on didn't help them in my eyes so I wouldn't recommend them.
(I'll be talking about players in order of list because it looks neater to me)
From everyone else, Ripple is the most consistent tr to me.
First of all. the fact that Ripple didn't place Pod in their proposed team for the first mission shows that clearly, they aren't just sheeping on Pod's perc claim and have an individual thought process.
I could be giving Ripple too much credit here (considering that they said:
Proposing a team without the perc claim can be considered really scummy or interesting. Keeping in mind that Pod did say to reject the first few missions anyway to develop reads, Ripple attempted to make a team based on what they liked which seemed townie to me.
Ripple made statements such as:
^ Those kind of reads are really townie to me and Ripple has consistently shown that kind of behaviour throughout this round. I'd recommend Ripple to be placed on the team.
Game Board