Imsohappy and I are the game moderators please PM this account if you have any questions also please don't kill us for making small mistakes because this is our 1st time hosting forum mafia.
doesnt jeff like death tunnel people though when hes town. that seems like a thing he does
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
all i asked was if you had meta, that solves it and his post was tonally town just not tonally town /enough/ for me to understand your read unless you had meta. If there's a big difference you're not being egotistical, right????
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
7 pages into d1, jeffrey aaron has a 100% read that he refuses to reconsider.
i might be a little bit egotistical/hasty in my read because i generally consider myself really good at reading shrub, and in normal mafia games i almost never misread him, because the difference in tone between his town/mafia play is huge. i am getting tonally town vibes from him here, but i get that i could be wrong because this is different.
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Have you played with shrubs before to know he couldn't force the tone in that post? Because it's BARELY towny. Maybe you're confbiased bc you already know he's town
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
like they're the most basic reads you could pick, minus the read on antidote, but the only reason the last one isn't basic is because i had already outed a TR on him.
Sorry I'll try to be more wallposty shrubs, I understand your logic in that
antidote made one post and it was to say "er" at daystart which is the easiest thing to push on short of what i just pointed out about what you just said. Actually scratch that, it's easier to push on than what I just said by a decent amount. That's not the same as it being scummy.
Snk is a forum troll but thecolonel plays mafia and I expect them both to be trollish throughout but that doesn't mean they're unreadable, although I see they both only posted filler so far.
Ok I'll just start by saying two kinda non strictly content related things that I don't want you to tr me based on
Could everyone please try to keep the random filler post to a minimum and post in large blocks as opposed to lost of small posts becaus it was a nightmare rereading in the last forum Mafias I've been a part of and I would like to be able to reread content without losing brain cells. Secondly I'm really dissapointed in not flipping Mafia in any forum Mafia to date - I don't want you to tr me for this I just wanted to kinda put it out there.
I do expect you to townread me for my content though.
Ele is obvious town, I don't think anyone is going to argue with me there. You can all make your own conclusions on that I cbf elaborating.
I think Merlot is also town because their scum hunting random etc seemed to be genuine kinda flummoxed and confused town.
Matts scumhunting is genuine and I would be inclined to believe his reads but I expect him enough as a Mafia player to know that if he were Mafia he could force it with ease. People calling Matt town this early is not a good idea.
Pjm is null I could see him starting this way as either alignment
Gerry leans scum for me as I agree with MATT about the backpedal being fake and awful and although the trap card thing was a solid bit of banter it doesn't seem towny to me. I usually end up fosing his trolly antics and he eventually gets around to playing the game so we will see.
I think snk and colonel are going to be the useless lynchbaity players as either alignment so I'm not keen on lynching them today and anyone who ours reads on the, now I call bs on and that persons probably Mafia for forcing reads
Game Board