Back to Epicmafia

Best Epicmafia Role

SirAmelio
almost 10 years

Greetings people. Just for fun, let's have a tournament showing which is, for popular opinion, the best Epicmafia role.

I took all 143 official roles, plus Funnersmith since its the most popular custom role and, randomize them and put them in a challonge bracket.

When you vote think of which role you like the best, which one you would rather to roll over the other.

Here is the full bracket

http://challonge.com/BestRoleMafia

Current link

https://eSurv.org?u=BEMRR3

There will be 24ish hours to vote in each round btw so this will go relatively quick.

I'll probably make a sandbox setup featuring the 64 or 32 best roles or something.

Sportsfan666
almost 10 years
Is this double elimination? I think it's a little unfair that some good roles like Detective could be beaten purely because they were up against something great like Vent. Also, a role like Gallis could win over something worse like Secretary.
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
https://eSurv.org?u=BEMRR3


Round 2 is closed, lets go with round 3!
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
https://eSurv.org?u=BEMRR1B



Okay I decided to just close it, go here for the new round!
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
Last two hours to vote!
thatsoraven
almost 10 years
my custom role is best role.




GG
+k
I win
This game is unranked
Rogelio
almost 10 years
Poisoner is such a powerful role.

And mistletoe won over thief, lol
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
we are at 25 rn. had 55 last round!
shogungundam04
almost 10 years
Voted in round 1 and round 2!
deletedalmost 10 years
best role is vent
yoyoyorlozer
almost 10 years
this is making me realize just how bad 99% of epicmafia roles are
giovanni
almost 10 years

SirAmelio says

its only the official roles and funnersmith since its the most popular custom!!!


okay but you're totally missing the point which is that there is none if ABBA isn't on there
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
its only the official roles and funnersmith since its the most popular custom!!!
giovanni
almost 10 years
where's ABBA. trahs thread. no ABBA no point
EpicSides
almost 10 years
Voted
xramza
almost 10 years
My agenda is to push Granny and Terrorist as far as possible. This cannot be stopped.
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
Decided to divide round 2 in two parts since there are way too many questions. I'll finish this in around 24 hours.

https://eSurv.org?u=BEMRR2A
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
http://challonge.com/BestRoleMafia


First results are up! Second round starting up soon.


Pretty dissapointed Poisoner lost against Amnesiac when Poisoner is by far one of the best roles. As well as Stalker losing against Town Crier, but that was to be expected as Crier is a meme role.
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
also since i got quite a lot of responses i may just close this round tonight! stay tuned!
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
toreador can be good, just not in sandbox unless matched with a tailor or even better actress/stalker
Rogelio
almost 10 years
I like psychic, but I do not know if it is the best.

I am sure that toreador is the worst.
SirAmelio
almost 10 years

grifiest says

some vote was on bad x bad roles and some are good x good while the rests are good x bad lmao


completely randomized, oh well! yeah kinda sucks for the ones good x good so early
ChaoticDoom
almost 10 years
should've put golbolco in
grifiest
almost 10 years
some vote was on bad x bad roles and some are good x good while the rests are good x bad lmao
SirAmelio
almost 10 years
bumping
Kaioxys
almost 10 years
Jigsaw role is best. Hands down.