Top 10 Mafia Players

deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago

Only list players that you've actually played with.

For me it's (subject to change)

  1. Empire/Tatami
  2. Regfan/Maxwell
  3. Shivv
  4. Gira/animegayboy69
  5. Turquoise
  6. Jesusofnazareth
  7. Anthony
  8. Calvin/Jericho
  9. Brownpimp007 (pre-isp stage)
  10. Jeffreyaaron
roadmanabout 10 years ago
I tried writing a list and I honestly can't think of anyone worth mentioning. Shivv would be my top spot though.
roadmanabout 10 years ago
Brownpimp was overrated as shît.
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
some people fluke being good.
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
brownpimp legit couldn't read the game worth a sht and took a higher average winrate than everyone else in that he was lynched less
1
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
bombboy
Everyone is underestimating brownpimp imo that dude was a beast
brownpimp worked like a pressure release valve. he was purely a gimmick, people just went with him just because, nobody was called stupid for losing to him or whatever. trust the pimp, such bs lol
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
system copped on that townies omgus and mafia don't, and voiced it, and so for that i'll consider him half-decent
bombboyabout 10 years ago
Everyone is underestimating brownpimp imo that dude was a beast
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
and then you can derive other things from that little bit too, but i couldn't be arsed lol
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
Sincerely
so like with everything else?
nah, there's learning to everything else. there's very little actual depth to this game, people are incredibly simplistic in their responses to pressure and their actually building up what's going on in any particular game, and that's about all you need. you'll win most games just knowing that townies will tunnel, mafia won't, townies will omgus, mafia won't.
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
so like with everything else?
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
trilobite
i wanna make a list but i haven't played with the people people think are good players
there really is no list. there's a threshold that once u pass it, ur good. it's sort of like just having the key. after that the game reveals itself to u

so few people have passed it.
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
at least my list is more accurate than shrub's
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
trilobite
i wanna make a list but i haven't played with the people people think are good players
trilobiteabout 10 years ago
i wanna make a list but i haven't played with the people people think are good players
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
I didn't post here originally bc I don't know any of the retired players so I only came to post when tatami's thread reminded me, because I wanted to add to his count of people putting him in the list
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
Tatami
veryniceboy
gira was nowhere near as good as soben either
You've got a very bad pair of nostalgia goggles.
dude u think all these clowns playing fancy pants have brought about 'winrate deflation'
Simsabout 10 years agoedited
1. Gira
2. Maxwell
3. Crypto
4. Soben

i can honestly only think of 4 that are the GOAT
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
trilobite
Sincerely
tbh all I know is that it's like

Tatami
Hedger
Turquoise
Expose
Gerry
Ian
Cody
Nahdia
Bacde

in some order lol
liking someone doesn't make them good at mafia

i'm not even talking about me this time lol
I put you there because you're good at mafia. tHose are players I've played with enough to judge with the exception of possibly turquoise. I almost put giga on the list, whom I barely know, but thought was a good player
Becomeclearabout 10 years ago
is it weird that I cant think of a list?
I just play with whoever...
Tatamiabout 10 years ago
veryniceboy
gira was nowhere near as good as soben either
You've got a very bad pair of nostalgia goggles.
Tatamiabout 10 years ago
Nahdia is rock solid, she's not the best but she is consistently great.
trilobiteabout 10 years ago
Sincerely
tbh all I know is that it's like

Tatami
Hedger
Turquoise
Expose
Gerry
Ian
Cody
Nahdia
Bacde

in some order lol
liking someone doesn't make them good at mafia

i'm not even talking about me this time lol
deleteddeletedabout 10 years ago
gira was nowhere near as good as soben either
Sincerelyabout 10 years ago
GerrysGoat
Sincerely
tbh all I know is that it's like

Tatami
Hedger
Turquoise
Expose
Gerry
Ian
Cody
Nahdia
Bacde

in some order lol
this list is a bigger troll than the account i'm posting this on.
No, I just don't know that many players particularly well.

Nahdia is perhaps personal bias, and I don't really remember how well she played except that it was better than my play. Cody/Turquoise/Tatami/Gerry are all definitely players I'd stand behind though
Becomeclearabout 10 years ago
it gives off a vibe of legitimacy to the whole practice, though.
Either way my last tryhard games were bout 6 months ago.. I might pick up some form now that I've a bit more free time and try to run