Round 301 Discussion

janaover 11 years ago

Congratulations to the winners of Round 300!

Good luck to the participants of Round 301!

Join the competition!!

deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
UniversalStudios
Twist
Memes and good times shouldn't be used together.
False.
Puushing things from years ago also isn't something that should be done.
hedgerover 11 years ago
Mods you do realise if you actually stick to guidelines/rules/precedents, you won't get half the hate you do, cause at least you have those backing you up. Instead you make yourselves look like fools by making judgment calls where everyone's opinions are going to be different.
UniversalStudiosover 11 years ago
Was town at fault for lynching the clear?
hedgerover 11 years ago
mist
games are refunded if the team that got thrown against was at a significant advantage and they lost as a direct result of the throw. at least that's what the rule says :\

edit: sorry not rules, guidelines
"they lost as a direct result of the throw"

Somehow I'm failing to see how the mods made the right decision in this case.
OldProover 11 years ago
helsinki
If the only difference between a refund and no refund is the sole living clear getting mled because he didn't claim and lynched at lylo because he didn't claim then you probably have too literal an interpretation of a "spirit of the game" rule
there is nothing wrong with literal interpretations. if a literal interpretation leads to an illogical conclusion such as this, the blame lies in parameters.
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
you got every pair of jordans that come out but you can only text when ur phone got wifi lmaooo i actually know a dude like that too
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
UniversalStudios
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UCArDfYB4o
the guy who made that vid had a few of videos on worldstar before and he was hella unfunny. this one is decent though
UniversalStudiosover 11 years ago
Don't they give violations for that? That would be a funny .gif to get a violation for.
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
If the only difference between a refund and no refund is the sole living clear getting mled because he didn't claim and lynched at lylo because he didn't claim then you probably have too literal an interpretation of a "spirit of the game" rule
UniversalStudiosover 11 years ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UCArDfYB4o
UniversalStudiosover 11 years ago
Twist
Memes and good times shouldn't be used together.
False.
OldProover 11 years ago
devante, there is no way to know if town would have won. that is why it shouldn't have been refunded under current guidelines.

however uncertain the outcome was, town was denied the proper use of a misynch by lynching a PR. it significantly decreased their odds.
OldProover 11 years ago
would you rather have refund scrubbers have an advantage, or have people with gamethrowing friends have an advantage?
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
OldPro
its actually a significant advantage compared to what happened.
orc was dead, a noob blue was clear. the noob blue had 2 town reads, the noob blue lead on the bp because of whatever reason. Even if the noob blue had lynched a mafia day 1, the noob blue would have died, leaving the noob BP alive and the noob bp probably had no real reads, the rest of the town had fos'd each other from what I read on the forums (I only read day 1 of the game) but someone implied that people had abunch of bad reads.

i don't see town winning that game anyways but... Refer to the gif at the top of this page
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
OldPro
no wonder game-throwers are rampant. if they merely put town at a significant disadvantage, no refund.
it makes sense since before people would report for almost anything in hopes to get a refund. hell, pranay still does it.
OldProover 11 years ago
its actually a significant advantage compared to what happened.
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
Memes and good times shouldn't be used together.
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
i miss when those meme was taking over twitter. good times, good times.
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
well, at it's best that game was going to 4 way no clears, that's not really an advantage for the team that lost.... .... . .


OldProover 11 years ago
i agree with this refund, but i am from another time. this clearly doesn't match the current guidelines as a refundable game
OldProover 11 years ago
no wonder game-throwers are rampant. if they merely put town at a significant disadvantage, no refund.
deleteddeletedover 11 years agoedited
games are refunded if the team that got thrown against was at a significant advantage and they lost as a direct result of the throw. at least that's what the rule says :\

edit: sorry not rules, guidelines
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
Yo did I really just get blamed for the zhuorb trophy

Zovea owns, I should go find some post from him 48 hours ago about how I'm the only good mod
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
yeah that's an interesting refunded games i think i've seen worse cases get refunded. you could argue that the naked blue did say he town read giga and pop, so had the bp claimed maybe he would've lynched mafia... but he was going to die that night so even if he did lynch mafia, the clear would've been the bp who got lynched who might have had different reads. Plus aren't games only refunded if there's no chance of town winning due to the actions of the person being reported.

town coulda.. still won... i think? maybe?
justrecover 11 years ago
Giga13
justrec
giga dodged 90% of tables available when he ran only to not win a trophy
you were saying
you dodged every single table only to win a bronze from a refunded game
1