Round 228 Discussion

Jaspraralmost 12 years ago

Congratulations to the winners of Round 227!


pozzy

Setups

Searching For Bernin

Who Watches the Watcher?


Twelve

Setups

Kittenz Was the Hooker 2.0

Glenngary Glenn Ross


Subolg

Setups

Politics as Usual

Godfather Hunt V2


Good luck to the participants of Round 228!

Stevenalmost 12 years ago
I agree. A lot of things are good, such as the neat stuff in this thread
1
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
We should focus more on what's good instead of always talking about how much everything sucks.
1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Every setup blows.
AsbelLhantalmost 12 years ago
neat stuff in this thread
1
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
Cantankerous
personally, i think lobk shoudl be recomp'd since if you give it gold heart games, i think it'll balance. or, at the very least, remake it for the competition.
System took it down of his own will, I didn't tell him to take it down. I mentioned to him that if someone complained it was too similar to original LOBL, which was comped recently, that he may have to, but it wasn't taken down for its imbalance. It's a super small sample size, besides.
Renaldoalmost 12 years agoedited
Have you played it?

It's obviously not perfect, but I wanted to make a no reveal setup where claiming day 1 is sub-optimal, as well as mafia multiple counterclaiming options (which is rare in 7-8 player setups).
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
personally, i think lobk shoudl be recomp'd since if you give it gold heart games, i think it'll balance. or, at the very least, remake it for the competition.
Clairalmost 12 years ago
i'm not calling it bad because of balance. i'm calling it bad because it looks bad, in theory
Renaldoalmost 12 years agoedited
Oh of course, I'm just saying calling my setup bad after a small sample size isn't exactly fair, when he touts how "ingenious" his own setup is, yet it is more imbalanced currently.

I like the LOBL variant I was just making a joke because he randomly brought up how terrible my own setup is.
catbaealmost 12 years agoedited
was in response to bronto
Clairalmost 12 years ago
it was emphasising your point, not answering
catbaealmost 12 years ago
I wasn't asking, I was making a point - very easy to make false assumptions about a setup's balance over a small sample
Kerryalmost 12 years ago
catbae
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup
[Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered](https://epicmafia.com/setup/1030927/):

What is sample size
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
also gira's setup is fine and only has a bad WR since red heart cheaters played a few games and rolled town
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
catbae
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup
[Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered](https://epicmafia.com/setup/1030927/):

What is sample size
About the same as my setup. ~45 plays.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
to be fair i'm basically the best freakin player ever.
catbaealmost 12 years agoedited
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup


[Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered](https://epicmafia.com/setup/1030927/):


What is sample size
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
imo i don't still don't have the gall to push against people who i can't concrete read and accept that i am bad in that retrospect given that i thought slow was scum tbh
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
winning as mafia means you have to fearkill n1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Giga
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup
Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered:

ɢᴇᴛ ʀᴇĸᴛ
ahahahahaha
Renaldoalmost 12 years ago
Man now my post looks crappy because I tried to edit a link.
Raisealmost 12 years ago
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup
Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered:

O_O
Gigaalmost 12 years ago
Renaldo
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup
Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered:

ɢᴇᴛ ʀᴇĸᴛ
Renaldoalmost 12 years agoedited
Connor
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1076534 this setup only gets attention because bronto made it. it's a terrible setup


[Lynch or Be Lynched, ingeniously remastered](https://epicmafia.com/setup/1030927/):

1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
https://epicmafia.com/game/3471837