Betrayal Ucklar For the most part, if most people have talked and the accused can come up with a plausible reason for shooting, it's fine. The only way its a violation is if you shoot so early in the day that it would be impossible to gather reads. The bottom line is you need to have at least a little bit of reasoning as to why you shot, and not just, "Oh, I have a gun. Yolo." There are always exceptions to rules~ The hipfiring rule only applies to townies shooting.
Sanctify Betrayal shut the fuxk up you know good and well that I you fire before people speak you hipfired. You fired with ZERO READS. This is a TEXT BASED GAME. If this was real life you could argue that your reads were body language but it's not. You hipfired you broke a rule it's that's simple. Sanctify who do u think ur talking to kiddo, u dont tell me what to do! also what if I was cop and had guilty and shot my guilty and he was MILLER, do I get a violation for gamethrowing because I didnt know any better? Or is that cool?
Sanctify Ucklar Betrayal Okay then the next time a town hipfires me and im mafia, im reporting them and getting my refund. These kinds of situations can be cause for refunds, but it varies game by game.
I don't need to read the game to know that Betrayal was, indeed, trolling in whatever sparked this thread
Ucklar For the most part, if most people have talked and the accused can come up with a plausible reason for shooting, it's fine. The only way its a violation is if you shoot so early in the day that it would be impossible to gather reads. The bottom line is you need to have at least a little bit of reasoning as to why you shot, and not just, "Oh, I have a gun. Yolo." okay but you havent answered, what if I'm nilla and after saccing the COP n1, I decide to hipfire a townie and that townie was doc. Do I have to explain myself or is that gamethrowing and I deserve to be banned/vio for it? roflmao
Betrayal shut the fuxk up you know good and well that I you fire before people speak you hipfired. You fired with ZERO READS. This is a TEXT BASED GAME. If this was real life you could argue that your reads were body language but it's not. You hipfired you broke a rule it's that's simple.
For the most part, if most people have talked and the accused can come up with a plausible reason for shooting, it's fine. The only way its a violation is if you shoot so early in the day that it would be impossible to gather reads. The bottom line is you need to have at least a little bit of reasoning as to why you shot, and not just, "Oh, I have a gun. Yolo."
Steven dennings If hipfiring's automatic gamethrowing, you need to remove vig from ranked night start setups because they're shooting their gun without getting reads. Signed, sealed, delivered.
Your move, mods.
Hipfire is playing mafia on Hard Mode
dennings If hipfiring's automatic gamethrowing, you need to remove vig from ranked night start setups because they're shooting their gun without getting reads. Hey I've tried to say this for a long time but people dont listen :/
The idea that gamethrowing isn't tied to the intention is silly. You can be playing suboptimally and not gamethrow, everyone knows that
Ucklar Betrayal Okay then the next time a town hipfires me and im mafia, im reporting them and getting my refund. Ucklar you're a moron, it wouldn't be refunded.. The person who hipfired would get a violation and that's it.
Ucklar Betrayal Ucklar Betrayal Satan pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game Okay and who determines what a hipfire is vs a non-hipfire hmm?
how can you differentiate between someone who hipfired versus someone who did not
is their a time allotted to when hipfiring isnt hipfiring? There isn't a systematic approach to what constitutes a hipfire therefore this law is ridiculous.
Betrayal Ucklar Betrayal Satan pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game Hipfiring is hipfiring. It doesn't matter the consequence of the action. It will still be a violation.
Ucklar Hipfiring is now trolling for w/e reason, but it was always illegal. Okay I demand that you talk to your superiors and have that law changed, I think that it is unjust and ruins the quality of mafia games. People are no longer taking risks in mafia like they used to thanks to this stupid law.
Edark Hipfire doesnt automatically means your intention is to lose the game on purpose exactly my point! people hipfire with the intention to shoot the mafia, they dont intend to hipfire wrong when hipfiring
If hipfiring's automatic gamethrowing, you need to remove vig from ranked night start setups because they're shooting their gun without getting reads.
Hipfiring is now trolling for w/e reason, but it was always illegal.
Hipfire doesnt automatically means your intention is to lose the game on purpose
Ucklar Betrayal Satan pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game okay but what if I hipfire a townie as mafia
do town can the ability to report me because im doing my job and getting rid of town as mafia?
Ucklar Betrayal Ucklar Betrayal Okay then the next time a town hipfires me and im mafia, im reporting them and getting my refund. but how is hipfiring gamethrowing? if you have a gun, you should have a right to shoot it
why are there gun restriction laws that is BS and what constitutes a hipfire vs a normal shot
who is the judge of that
Betrayal Satan pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game You should stop hipfiring. It isn't playing towards your win condition, and all that will happen is that you will receive more violations,
Betrayal Ucklar Betrayal Okay then the next time a town hipfires me and im mafia, im reporting them and getting my refund. People do report it quite often lol. If they don't its their loss, not mine.
Satan pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game nope. i do it all the time and most of the time, im right
pretty sure it's physically impossible to get reads 1 second into the game
Poll
