Drawing over Auto Loss for Town

deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago

In a situation where you are a member of the town forced into a meteor due to scum NKing and it is mylo, is it acceptable to force NL and draw the game over taking autoloss due to conflicting votes?

I feel this needs more public opinion and elaboration because I had a hard time deciding whether I felt this instance here was GT or not.

https://epicmafia.com/report/110662 - sneak https://epicmafia.com/report/110795 - shifter

I initially felt it was a note given the circumstances put under them, as sneak (in this case) was forced to either vote her town-read or NL due to Kart being insistent on her vote, but had dissenting opinions from another mod (and Kart herself) that the intent was clearly there in sneak's case to just draw it over taking a loss. You can read my comments in the report section as to what I was thinking at the time.

Edit: Please read the game and reports before posting.

Poll
your opinion:
GT64%9
Not GT35%5
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
If the options are force NL and lose or vote and lose 100% then no, it's not GT.

If voting allows a chance of winning, and instead they force a draw, then yes, it is.
1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
it is gt-- because-- forcing nl meant certain loss-- lynching meant he had a chance if his townread was wrong-- which is always a possibility for idiots like this--- if he was so sure on his townread, then he was supposed to vote first so that the other person is compelled to vote his way. it is gt, because he was this sure. and its obvious why he was so sure. he was using outside game methods to find mafia.
Clairalmost 12 years ago
however, it's clear that sneak was uninformed about how "ties" (mutual loss) works. so i guess, in reality, it wasn't gamethrowing. depends how red-tapist you wanna be
Clairalmost 12 years ago
technically i think you're supposed to treat all cases of ignorance as GT as there is a message at the top of the day informing them that it is indeed a loss by NLing
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Connor
sneak needs to be informed that theres no such thing as a f*cking tie and they are a moron
but is it GT or no, iyo
Clairalmost 12 years ago
sneak needs to be informed that theres no such thing as a f*cking tie and they are a moron