Classic Mafia Problems.

Isheariaabout 12 years ago

So, we've all seen it happen. You're playing cop and on D1 the mafia outs first, "Guilty Ishearia!" they say. Luckily, you've got a guilty on their partner, so you out it, "I CC, guilty your partner!" you say, before NL'ing to avoid a fourway. So you have both mafia on D1, this is perhaps the worst position to be in on Epic Mafia, because there is no reason for you to get another report, there are two mafia and you know whom they both are from your point of view on D1, so you have all the inno's and all the guilties you'll need. Yet, now you have to decide who you'll go on with your D2 report. You have three options of course; you could check that whomever it is that CC'd you isn't trolling, however that puts you at risk of being called a noob by the town for checking your CC; you could check somebody random and out an inno, but there's no reason to do this if you have two mafia and a clever towny might decide that because you felt the need to check somebody else when you should already know whom is inno and whom isn't that you must not have realised the fact and therefore will scumread you, because that makes sense right? The third option, of course, is to not investigate anybody. This makes sense logically, you have all the mafia, it's pretty much confirmed, a cop who's on the ball will realise that there's no use in getting another report assuming that your CC isn't just a trolling towny. So, I'd like to know what the most common interpretation of this very common problem is.

Poll
So, what shall it be? Do you:
Check a random to get an inno.54%13
Check your CC.41%10
Not investigate at all.4%1
AyaWindabout 12 years ago
i thought the right answer was to clear an inno asap but the right answer is actually to check your CC. if your cc is really guilty then you don't out your report on your guilty cc but fake a inno report on a random townie.

this is just in case your cc is a retarded troll and flips town
Theabout 12 years ago
You don't have to tell the town that you confirmed your cc. Since you know who is inno and who is not, you can play it off as if you checked someone else.
metalheadnvabout 12 years ago
Check your cc to confirm not troll and out random inno since you know all of them...
GuyFawkes85about 12 years ago
przes
Tbh I'd check a town and try to pick the best townie that's open-minded and will be more likely to see your side. This way it's possible you can gain an ally or create a clear inno who is competent and can lead well
This

Miloo7
Whatever you do, do not investigate your CC. Since sometimes people might be stupid and CC you as blue; In case they die you need to have reports on alive. BTW not investigating?! Just no.
and this.
Miloo7about 12 years ago
Whatever you do, do not investigate your CC. Since sometimes people might be stupid and CC you as blue; In case they die you need to have reports on alive. BTW not investigating?! Just no.
deleteddeletedabout 12 years agoedited
Bad Players' Problems
przesabout 12 years ago
Tbh I'd check a town and try to pick the best townie that's open-minded and will be more likely to see your side. This way it's possible you can gain an ally or create a clear inno who is competent and can lead well
2
niceabout 12 years ago
this is a dumb question. if u check ur cc and they turn up guilty, u have two guilties and u can fake an inno on anybody.
2
junhoesabout 12 years ago
i'd check cc to see if they're trolling or not and if they are, then out it, and if they aren't, then say a fake report on someone who's inno. cuz u know who's inno and who's maf~ soo yeah :3
LIoydabout 12 years ago
In a perfect world where most of society does not have mush for a brain, you would check your cc. However as you said all of the idiots out there that refuse to think will say. YOU CHECKED YOUR CC...YOU NEVER CHECK YOUR CC...these people can only remember protocol they refuse to use logic. So you still check your cc to make sure they are not trolling, but you just TELL the town (that cannot get their head around having no reason to check anyone else) what THEY want to here give an inno or say you checked no one...


There is also the option of refusing to vote on day one...and explain to the whole town what spot you will be in that night AND TELL THEM ALL......I WILL BE CHECKING MY CC......If the unintelligent town STILL can't understand it and you do not want to be lynched for no reason..just let them pick their check for you. (and then lie to them the next day and say you checked their pick)

Because with idiots; You can explain it to them, but you can't understand it for them.
5
Jalebabout 12 years ago
The correct answer is you lynch d1 in cop cc's in this god awful setup so you don't have to worry about dumb d2 cop reports that wont matter.