Round 750 Discussion Thread!

mukialmost 8 years ago

Congrats to all three winners of Round 749!


1st

Setups:


2nd

Setups:


3rd

Setups:


Good luck to the participants of Round 750!

Join the competition!

^ Me when I'm in a game with Ally

Poll
What setup would you like to see featured next round? (Make suggestions for next round's poll in the comments!)
Guns & Hookers33%7
Fool Training 328%6
Masquerade Ball14%3
Great and Innovative9%2
Carbon 14 Dawnstart9%2
Janitorial 2.04%1
Politics as Usual0%0
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
Town wins by getting the game finished before meteor too
In that setup - nope.
ShawnMichaelsalmost 8 years ago
Yesterday it had less sample size
LioneIalmost 8 years ago
Yesterday, it was 53:46 maf to town
ShawnMichaelsalmost 8 years ago
Balanced Cat stats 54 town/45 mafia. MafAllAlong, you got some 'splainin to do. In what cases is your setup ever mafsided?
blacksnakemoanalmost 8 years ago
Town wins by getting the game finished before meteor too
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years agoedited
You're thinking completely opposite and even not about forcing to lose. Town is losing, either way, upon meteor everybody loses. Mafia wins by getting the game finished before meteor.
blacksnakemoanalmost 8 years ago
PatrykSzczescie
You seem to make up conclusions without proper observations... as always.
Where'd I do that exactly?

Forcing mafia to lose = town advantage, no?
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
blacksnakemoan
You can't force mafia to lose just because you don't like the meteor mechanic.
MafAllAlong
Actually, town are the ones who can take advantage of the meteor.
See where I say one thing and you repeat it back to me with different words and start off with "Actually"

Meteor is fine. It forces people to act and make decisions instead of wimping out and making the other team do something.
You seem to make up conclusions without proper observations... as always.
deleteddeletedalmost 8 years ago
feature jfk next round please and thank you
blacksnakemoanalmost 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
You can't force mafia to lose just because you don't like the meteor mechanic.
MafAllAlong
Actually, town are the ones who can take advantage of the meteor.
See where I say one thing and you repeat it back to me with different words and start off with "Actually"

Meteor is fine. It forces people to act and make decisions instead of wimping out and making the other team do something.
MafAllAlongalmost 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
MafAllAlong
it needs to be made against the rules in this setup to force meteor if in auto loss. its a simple fix
meteor is perfectly fine. It's a stalemate. You can't force mafia to lose just because you don't like the meteor mechanic.

Remember that anytime there's a meteor on mafia, town have 3 chances to lynch and take control.

You need to rethink your setup if it's won't work unless meteor is removed.
Actually, town are the ones who can take advantage of the meteor. The meteor mechanic is not broken only in this setup, it is theoretically broken in any setup where the last mafia alive doesn't have a killing night action. That needs to be looked into.
blacksnakemoanalmost 8 years ago
MafAllAlong
it needs to be made against the rules in this setup to force meteor if in auto loss. its a simple fix
meteor is perfectly fine. It's a stalemate. You can't force mafia to lose just because you don't like the meteor mechanic.

Remember that anytime there's a meteor on mafia, town have 3 chances to lynch and take control.

You need to rethink your setup if it's won't work unless meteor is removed.
1
Roleblockeralmost 8 years ago
PatrykSzczescie
This setup is always a town win if town lynches two mafs and shoots the third when GS doesn't die N2.
to me this setup is luckbased. even if seer is lynched town has a high win chance because of gun.
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years ago
This setup is always a town win if town lynches two mafs and shoots the third when GS doesn't die N2.
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years ago
Another scenario is when town shoots the second mafia, which shouldn't happen if town plays well.

Anyway, in those cases you don't lynch the mafia. You sacrifice a town and try gunning somebody who's not gonna be killed or robbed.
MafAllAlongalmost 8 years ago
PatrykSzczescie
MafAllAlong
it needs to be made against the rules in this setup to force meteor if in auto loss. its a simple fix
You must fix the setup with must lynch, which will make it more mafsided if thief successfully steals a gun as last mafia, it would be well deserved though.
must-lynch would absolutely mafside this setup in plenty of scenarios.
PatrykSzczesciealmost 8 years ago
MafAllAlong
it needs to be made against the rules in this setup to force meteor if in auto loss. its a simple fix
You must fix the setup with must lynch, which will make it more mafsided if thief successfully steals a gun as last mafia, it would be well deserved though.
shadyalmost 8 years ago
I don't see how mafia deserved to have meteor there when they are performing their action responsibly each night, seems like an exploit used by town that has no place in the setup
MafAllAlongalmost 8 years ago
denial
MafAllAlong
denial
MafAllAlong
Also why on earth are meteor mechanics that the game goes unranked if whoever has meteor doesn't take action. That makes no sense at all.
maybe try must lynch?
Impossible the setup fundamentally relies on town being able to no lynch at times. This is because if they lynch the final maf then the final maf gets to pick out who the seer is and wins.
yeah, you honestly made a pretty good setup with the seer involved, but will is correct that town are given the option to force meteor there, which kinda breaks the setup in that very rare situation they were in
It is an obscure situation and thats the only time its been exploited thus far in the setups history. The setup is perfectly balanced otherwise and most people like it a lot. Is there any way we can get a rule imposed that people can't force meteor like that purposefully on this setup. Meteor is of no use in this setup other then to exploit this glitch. Or is there any other possible fix?
denialalmost 8 years ago
MafAllAlong
denial
MafAllAlong
Also why on earth are meteor mechanics that the game goes unranked if whoever has meteor doesn't take action. That makes no sense at all.
maybe try must lynch?
Impossible the setup fundamentally relies on town being able to no lynch at times. This is because if they lynch the final maf then the final maf gets to pick out who the seer is and wins.
yeah, you honestly made a pretty good setup with the seer involved, but will is correct that town are given the option to force meteor there, which kinda breaks the setup in that very rare situation they were in
MafAllAlongalmost 8 years ago
denial
MafAllAlong
Also why on earth are meteor mechanics that the game goes unranked if whoever has meteor doesn't take action. That makes no sense at all.
maybe try must lynch?
Impossible the setup fundamentally relies on town being able to no lynch at times. This is because if they lynch the final maf then the final maf gets to pick out who the seer is and wins.
dzanek1143almost 8 years ago
Actually, all players lose a heart if meteor occurs.
denialalmost 8 years ago
MafAllAlong
Also why on earth are meteor mechanics that the game goes unranked if whoever has meteor doesn't take action. That makes no sense at all.
maybe try must lynch?
PonyLovealmost 8 years ago
AWW THE PUPPY <3<3<3
10
mukialmost 8 years ago
D3xTr0m3th0rph4n
I cant see any of the pics, but the gif better be two hot girls sharing an icecream cone or something..or else i will be extremely disappointed in you MW
Yes, that is how I feel when I'm in a game with Ally lmao gg
1