fake claiming/rs/trolling

deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago

hi to all of you wonderful people, with the exception of our missing europeans, i come bringing a thread to discuss a rule.....

where do you think the line between fake claiming/attempted rs and a trolling violation should be?

Is it okay to fake claim as town? How often can you do? in what situations can you do it and not do it as town? at what point might this become trolling (or even gting)?

please discuss

Poll
how long will europe be banned?
they are banned for life89%25
1 week3%1
1month3%1
3 months3%1
1 day0%0
3days0%0
5 day0%0
2weeks0%0
3 weeks0%0
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
Ra1nyDay
blacksnakemoan
it's not strategy if you do it in every game and everyone knows you do it
do you scum hunt in every game? does everyone know you do it? is that not a strategy?
you know what i mean, stop twisting.

scumhunting is the game.

your bs tactics are not.

it's not strategy to claim orc, caroler, and sheriff in the one game so everyone claims. because then you look scummy and die.

you don't seem to get that. the vast majority of the competitive playerbase gets annoyed with how you play because you dont make it easier for whatever team you're on
If i dont troll i get auto lynched dude when i am blue. when i claim like this, i get blue read and not lynched as much. they may get annoyed by this but they are equally annoyed when they lynch me as a scummy town.

I have 4 trophies, so i do not think that i am clueless how to play. we all have our own strategies that work here so stop trying to control them unless they are making it unfair to the other players. i argue that fake claiming is not unfair for them!
Zhuorbabout 8 years ago
I for one find claiming all roles but mine to be very fruitful since it baits the mafia into claiming my role for easier scumhunting
1
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years ago
Ra1nyDay
blacksnakemoan
it's not strategy if you do it in every game and everyone knows you do it
do you scum hunt in every game? does everyone know you do it? is that not a strategy?
you know what i mean, stop twisting.

scumhunting is the game.

your bs tactics are not.

it's not strategy to claim orc, caroler, and sheriff in the one game so everyone claims. because then you look scummy and die.

you don't seem to get that. the vast majority of the competitive playerbase gets annoyed with how you play because you dont make it easier for whatever team you're on
1
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
calciumkid
but dont u get it there really shouldnt be a properly, the games about deception. Lynching someone because they claimed different roles in one game is lazy. But then again what do we expect from ppl who still guilty test.
beautifully said. this really bothers me with people. they play a thinking game and dont want to think. while i often do some common things, i dont play every game the same. i dont even troll every game!
deleteddeletedabout 8 years agoedited
Shoopie
People don't complain over every person fake claiming and deceiving. A lot complain about her.
How are you able to read all this and still say its one game? I'm happy you're here to have her back and all but there would be a lot less problems if she would listen to other people around her instead of playing and sticking with one strat like it's fancy pants.
i have only fake claimed every game for like a few months now. previously there were still an equal number of complaints about me: im a gt account, a slow role, i play dumb, etc. i cant ever please anyone here and i would get reported for something no matter what.

the question in this thread is when can you fake claim and not. what is the line so i know what i can and can't cross...

also if my strategy is broken and not working, how am i competitive to even win trophies?
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
it's not strategy if you do it in every game and everyone knows you do it
do you scum hunt in every game? does everyone know you do it? is that not a strategy?
Shoopieabout 8 years ago
Anywhoo thats my take on it. Good luck mtlve hope you learn something that works for you.
Shoopieabout 8 years ago
People don't complain over every person fake claiming and deceiving. A lot complain about her.
How are you able to read all this and still say its one game? I'm happy you're here to have her back and all but there would be a lot less problems if she would listen to other people around her instead of playing and sticking with one strat like it's fancy pants.
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
but dont u get it there really shouldnt be a properly, the games about deception. Lynching someone because they claimed different roles in one game is lazy. But then again what do we expect from ppl who still guilty test.
1
Shoopieabout 8 years ago
calciumkid
its the peoples fault fof being so one dimensional not mtlve fault for playing a mafia game the way it should be.

lol some of u just want everyonr to claim their role with honesty. gtfo dumb b!tchez.
It's not like they're complaining about every person who does it. Because other people do it properly. You're just helping the underdog.
1
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
its the peoples fault fof being so one dimensional not mtlve fault for playing a mafia game the way it should be.

lol some of u just want everyonr to claim their role with honesty. gtfo dumb b!tchez.
ivanaabout 8 years ago
Mtlve you just claimed 3 different roles for 4 games in a row. You can't get mad when people want to lynch you for your constant role claims. The difference is RS isn't something that is done every game, it tends to be a rarer thing. Not every game. I think that's the point here.
Shoopieabout 8 years agoedited
Lotta forums out of the same nut who was told to chill guess you didn't listen to a single thing I said.

Your strategies cause problems. If its not working its not a strategy is it? No. Now it's just a report farm.
How many hours does the mod team need to spend with you before you get it? If something is broken, you fix it or throw it out and get something new. Your. "STRATEGY" is broken. Fix it or get something new.

Not only that but you reuse the same tired, broken strat over and over. You can't even add variety to a strat that isn't working. Give up on it and move on. God.

On a personal level I think you're alright. But as a user you are the most stubborn little spitfire, You couldn't listen to another person to save your life but holy moly CAN YOU EVER TALK.
1
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years ago
it's not strategy if you do it in every game and everyone knows you do it
1
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
Ra1nyDay
blacksnakemoan
u cant do it for 4 months while being told not to multiple times and then claim its a strategy when people just see it as u being an idiot
you have no right to pick and choose which strategies are allowed or not beyond what the rules say
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
u cant do it for 4 months while being told not to multiple times and then claim its a strategy when people just see it as u being an idiot
you have no right to pick and choose which strategies are allowed or not beyond what the rules say
Heckabout 8 years ago
i mean i got away with it for 2508 games and counting
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years ago
u cant do it for 4 months while being told not to multiple times and then claim its a strategy when people just see it as u being an idiot
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
i want this answered now, especially by nathan and mods
BeepBeepLettuceabout 8 years ago
also

https://epicmafia.com/game/6577187
Harkinianabout 8 years ago
yyyit'sbenn

1
BeepBeepLettuceabout 8 years ago
they are banned until all of their violations against humanity expire

currently, they are serving their 100 year ban bc of hit|er
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
do it whenever thr fk u want.
MonteCarrloabout 8 years ago
ban JM123
13
yachiabout 8 years ago
no vio