← Back to Epicmafia

List of idiots who guilty test mk 2

Transcendover 8 years ago

Loljk

But please stop guilty testing there's a plethora of reasons why you don't. In fact if you have a guilty you shouldn't even out it.

If lawyer

  • will fish doc 9/10 times

  • if maf busses them town gets auto lynched

  • if you hide guilty, they might claim pr and be confirmed scum. But do that once jan is lynched.

If Miller

  • and maf guilties them town is immediately fkd

  • if lynched as blue, sends the game to lylo. Being in lylo is never good.

  • has the chance to become clear in most scenarios

  • when a miller gets guiltied, they town tell to all fk and you can have them as a tr.

  • if you hide the guilty, mafia might kill your guilty at night

Addendum: it's acceptable to lynch a guilty if they're scummy. But be absolutely sure you're right instead of blind lynching.

So just stop. Thank.

Poll
Guilty test?
No70%14
Yes30%6
20 votes
stdbrainover 8 years ago
Cymraeg
Giga13
Also BiggusDickus knows his shít
And you don't apparently. Look at the video linked on his profile: you did a lot of the math wrong man.
Bro I thought it's been confirmed since 2013 that every account with Giga in its name is a GT alt
Giga13over 8 years agoedited
Cymraeg
Giga13
Also BiggusDickus knows his shít
And you don't apparently. Look at the video linked on his profile: you did a lot of the math wrong man.
thank you. could you please point out where i made mistakes so that i may fix this in the video description? i made a couple of small errors which i acknowledged; it's going to happen when i freely try going over most jan 2.0 scenarios without a script in a 30 minute video and dragging icons all over the place
deleteddeletedover 8 years ago
Giga13
Also BiggusDickus knows his shít
And you don't apparently. Look at the video linked on his profile: you did a lot of the math wrong man.
Giga13over 8 years ago
Also BiggusDickus knows his shít
Giga13over 8 years ago
This might sound harsh but anybody who uses anecdotal evidence while arguing this topic isn't worth listening to
Thoughtover 8 years ago
I only guilty test in games with soda in them.
PatrykSzczescieover 8 years agoedited
https://epicmafia.com/game/6523892/view

Copped miller with naked janitor, lynched outside all the time, after lynched lawyer miller got a hammer and mishammered on lylo.

Literally, miller is never clear even if lawyer lynched. Town doesn't know who was lawyed.

If town lynched real maf when doc lived, they'd have most likely fished for doc. (9/10 times)
mattover 8 years ago
https://epicmafia.com/game/6525156/review

copped miller n1, they died n3

kept that information privileged

you should try it yourself (:
blacksnakemoanover 8 years ago
@Denial read the game, he basically just jumped on the guilty as a crutch for not having reads

btw if Pranay trophies this round he officially owns every one who guilty tests in any game he's in

like you should give dedicate your lives to him because he warned you what he would do in this thread and you all bloody did it
TownHunterover 8 years agoedited
Thank God someone understands English, here.
(talking about denial, btw. In case it wasn't clear to the others)

denial
his point is that theres a difference between lynching somebody because they're guilty to test a cop claim and lynching somebody because they're scummy and guiltied (meaning they're likely the lawyer)

one makes you an idiot and the other is not

(literally sodas addendum in this thread)


meh x not was my edit (for more accuracy)
denialover 8 years ago
his point is that theres a difference between lynching somebody because they're guilty to test a cop claim and lynching somebody because they're scummy and guiltied (meaning they're likely the lawyer)

one makes you an idiot and the other is meh

(literally sodas addendum in this thread)
2
blacksnakemoanover 8 years ago
TownHunter
JM123
https://epicmafia.com/game/6524545

to add:
faZ aka FearDarkness aka etc
4rtistic
TownHunter

we lost the game precisely due to the guilty testing lol
Someone tell JM what guilty testing means.

I was lynching my lawyer fos, flipped miller, maf guessed it. Lucky, gg wp.
You literally lynched a guilty when you had cop CCs. That's guilty testing. And like I tell people every game, Pranay wasted your mislynch by doing it, AND he got lucky and hit miller.
DoctorXover 8 years ago
dzanek1143
Let's be honest, uncc'd clear cop guilties should be lynched. It's not a test when cop is clear, mafia won't kill the guilty.

Especially when it's N1'd orc on nilla/janitor - you don't kill the useless naked role for another ml which looks similar - you lynch the guilty, who can be 2/3 mafia and it guarantees legit inno reports when the 2/3 hits in.
dzanek, those aren't tests. The idea of a test is to find real cop. In those cases you DO lynch the guilties like you said, but those aren't tests :)
TownHunterover 8 years ago
JM123
https://epicmafia.com/game/6524545

to add:
faZ aka FearDarkness aka etc
4rtistic
TownHunter

we lost the game precisely due to the guilty testing lol
Someone tell JM what guilty testing means.

I was lynching my lawyer fos, flipped miller, maf guessed it. Lucky, gg wp.
BiggusDickusover 8 years ago
THEY USE ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE TO JUSTIFY THEIR DUNNING-KREUGER FUELED DESECRATION OF A SOLVED SETUP
BiggusDickusover 8 years ago
dzanek1143
Give me a point why lynching the cc of guiltying cop is better than lynching the guilty.
THEY DONT HAVE ONE
dzanek1143over 8 years ago
Give me a point why lynching the cc of guiltying cop is better than lynching the guilty.
dzanek1143over 8 years ago
Let's be honest, uncc'd clear cop guilties should be lynched. It's not a test when cop is clear, mafia won't kill the guilty.

Especially when it's N1'd orc on nilla/janitor - you don't kill the useless naked role for another ml which looks similar - you lynch the guilty, who can be 2/3 mafia and it guarantees legit inno reports when the 2/3 hits in.
1
JM123over 8 years ago
https://epicmafia.com/game/6524545

to add:
faZ aka FearDarkness aka etc
4rtistic
TownHunter

we lost the game precisely due to the guilty testing lol
deleteddeletedover 8 years ago
https://epicmafia.com/game/6524545

Thanks for guilty testing and giving free maf wins to me.

Just as I predicted earlier in this thread.
deleteddeletedover 8 years ago
yeah jan 2.0 is really townsided if people follow the right strategies
BiggusDickusover 8 years ago
YOU DON'T EVEN GUILTY TEST IN BV. THAT STRATEGY WOULD BE SUBOPTIMAL. YOU LEAVE AS MANY REPORTS ALIVE FOR THE ENDGAME AND, ESPECIALLY WITH SUSPECTS OVER MILLERS, THEY SOLVE IT. HAVE YOU EVER PLAYED IT?
BiggusDickusover 8 years ago
/ourguy/ BIGGUS 13/13 GUILTY TESTING AT EVERY OPPORTUNITY AND FOLLOWING GIGA'S PRS CLAIM AS PR STRAT ON D2.

JANITORIAL IS TOWNSIDED YOU FOOLS. STOP IGNORING MATH.
1
BiggusDickusover 8 years ago
Psy
Only trash players lynch off of statistics. Gives them an excuse to be wrong and not have to put any effort into reading a player
DUNNING KREUGER
deleteddeletedover 8 years ago
This setup is designed for guilty testing scrubs

https://epicmafia.com/setup/1354150