Back to Epicmafia

Sandbox new official setup

moonlightseal
over 9 years

With 7 or sth new roles in November, some role seem outdated or balanced enough to get in or out of the setup

Please don't add in whisperer and telepath, they aren't fun

Toreador should be removed as well until all his bugs are fixed

Monkey has Toreador kind of mechanic, so fix the bugs first

With Butterfly, Zombie can be added in now

Every other old role n last official setup is OK to remain the same

Every new role can come in, except Justice, we have mistletoe for that

What do you think?

Also gallishunter > gallisloudmouth, so remove gallis please

SirAmelio
over 9 years

ObitoSigma says

The only problem is that some people would not join games unless the setup has a lot of upvotes. So an official setup with 300+ upvotes is attractive.


i have never seen this happen tbh. most people dont even check the setups they join.
cub
over 9 years

ObitoSigma says

The only problem is that some people would not join games unless the setup has a lot of upvotes. So an official setup with 300+ upvotes is attractive.


people who only play games if they see upvotes are not valued
Golbolco
over 9 years
I host setups with high negative votes and people still fill it up.
sl0nderman
over 9 years

ObitoSigma says

The only problem is that some people would not join games unless the setup has a lot of upvotes. So an official setup with 300+ upvotes is attractive.


I host my own setup with only a a few upvotes, so do people like endo. People just join the next game if it's 12 players and closed roles
SirAmelio
over 9 yearsedited
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1371461


balanced sandbox setup 2.0


Differences with the first version:

-No keymaker
-Added Sidekick, Prosecutor, Butterfly, Snowman and Cutler


Differences with Official Sandbox Setup

-Its not so unfair with mafia.
desta
over 9 years
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1371188
SirAmelio
over 9 years
Ill make a new balanced setup adding some of the new roles this afternoon
ObitoSigma
over 9 years
The only problem is that some people would not join games unless the setup has a lot of upvotes. So an official setup with 300+ upvotes is attractive.
deletedover 9 years
If you don't want to host then you can't complain about the setup
deletedover 9 years

sl0nderman says

...or just make your own setup and play that


Think the point here is if moonlight doesn't want to host a game they don't want to constantly be faced with a terrible setup that everyone uses
Golbolco
over 9 years
Justice and Mistletoe work best when in a setup together. Being a hostile third, mistletoe can claim justice.

Also, I'm with Error and Sl0nd on this one. Don't have an official setup, it puts a damper on variety and engineering.
deletedover 9 years
'glass man' should be in the official setup

https://epicmafia.com/role/6723
deletedover 9 years
yeah i can't say i'm too fond of the title of "official" for any sandbox setup.
sl0nderman
over 9 years
...or just make your own setup and play that