To the mafia: Nice try. None of you played necessarily bad. Just a bit of bad luck with the night actions and being surrounded by so many obv town.
Ripple: I had you pegged super super early I felt your tone was off and your posts were pretty forced. However, you know me too well and how I read people. I think you knew I would SR UltraAug and possibly used that to your advantage. I wish I didn't give you benefit of the doubt for one day. On top of that, your fake claim was really good actually. and I half bought it. However, your feud with Shamu was basically the nail in the coffin for you. That and Jeff threatening to out my bluff if I didn't vote you. You didn't play bad this game Claire and your scum play is still really good.
Shamu: You played a pretty good scum game for your first (legit) forum mafia game here. I'm proud of you. I think some of your posts were a bit off and ingenuine. Which is why I was a component of lynching you. However, you did a good job at pretending you were game solving. I did doubt my read on you a few times and waffled quite a bit. As you said, your feud with Ripple was a bit too theatrical. So for that and your claim, you ate a lynch.
Gerry: I had you pegged as mafia immediately as well. However then you just started to troll the game and bluff a lot and your progression through the game actually looked kinda genuine for the most part. At times I felt like you were fake scum-hunting. It's without question that you played the best out of your 3 partners. YOU WERE LITERALLY CONFIRMED SCUM BY BEING ROLEBLOCKED AND YOU MANAGED TO GET XXEROX LYNCHED. Pretty impressive bud. But unfortunately, that damned you quite a bit. Also the fact that your interactions with Ripple d1 contradicted heavily with your interactions with her d2. I said that you also might have had faux-rage but I didn't mark it as immediately scum because I've defended scum super hard like that as town before. Just put you on my "do not let live to LYLO list".
Ripple: I had you pegged super super early I felt your tone was off and your posts were pretty forced. However, you know me too well and how I read people. I think you knew I would SR UltraAug and possibly used that to your advantage. I wish I didn't give you benefit of the doubt for one day. On top of that, your fake claim was really good actually. and I half bought it. However, your feud with Shamu was basically the nail in the coffin for you. That and Jeff threatening to out my bluff if I didn't vote you. You didn't play bad this game Claire and your scum play is still really good.
Shamu: You played a pretty good scum game for your first (legit) forum mafia game here. I'm proud of you. I think some of your posts were a bit off and ingenuine. Which is why I was a component of lynching you. However, you did a good job at pretending you were game solving. I did doubt my read on you a few times and waffled quite a bit. As you said, your feud with Ripple was a bit too theatrical. So for that and your claim, you ate a lynch.
Gerry: I had you pegged as mafia immediately as well. However then you just started to troll the game and bluff a lot and your progression through the game actually looked kinda genuine for the most part. At times I felt like you were fake scum-hunting. It's without question that you played the best out of your 3 partners. YOU WERE LITERALLY CONFIRMED SCUM BY BEING ROLEBLOCKED AND YOU MANAGED TO GET XXEROX LYNCHED. Pretty impressive bud. But unfortunately, that damned you quite a bit. Also the fact that your interactions with Ripple d1 contradicted heavily with your interactions with her d2. I said that you also might have had faux-rage but I didn't mark it as immediately scum because I've defended scum super hard like that as town before. Just put you on my "do not let live to LYLO list".

