it could be that but if it seems like someone's reads ccannot be genuine and u think they (as a player) would have thought processes that appeared reasonable to you as town, at least in some areas, then one possible conclusion is their reads are fake or skewed
one bad read is not a good reason unless it's executed in a scummy manner, but consistently fake-seeming reads from a reasonable player seems worth voting
you could have trash reads, sure, but that's a risk you kind of have to take if you're going by your reads. If the player is town, tehy can defend themselves, ideally
oh btw wanna lynch transcend with me? he wrote you off as town for two posts even though he thought your reads were trash. I don't know if i'm jumping to conclusions about transcend because i was scum with him last game, but i don't think townscend would do that.
Game Board