Forum Mafia 15

deleteddeletedover 10 years ago

                                        It is endgame. Mafia wins.


Rules:

http://pastebin.com/Y6igF1wt

Mechanics/ Sample Role PM:

http://pastebin.com/2d7mex7z

Deadline and Procedure:

http://pastebin.com/i0yqmYQz

Special notes:

http://pastebin.com/SWjepVcC

Game Board
Pranay, Mafia GoonVictorious D4
Togepi, Mafia RolebockerVictorious D4
benjamin250, Town TrackerPlayed his last chess game D1
Kyle, Weak DoctorWent to heaven on holy sunday N2
Retti, Town BackupLurked too hard and died N3
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
with bullet points maybe
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
could you format them better
citeopmIover 10 years ago
Impoetic
justdance666
like she's probably not but some of her reasoning and logic in this game has been really bizarre
that's because I keep getting things about the game confused lol. Right now, specifically, what are you thinking of?
You knew what I meant by this question but dodged it by interpreting it literally on purpose as a joke.

Please answer the questions I asked above AND this one. Thanks.
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
i would get this kind of reaction if i were trying to lynch you but you're writing 1000+ words over saying you're a possible mafia, most of them being "other people think i'm town"
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
make it stop
citeopmIover 10 years ago
justdance666
i regret asking
well it should be pretty obvious since you tr'd me earlier
citeopmIover 10 years ago
I didn't push on mist when she intentionally made herself an easy target but pushed on her at other times.

I didn't use obvious reasons like, "he hammered PR, so we should lynch him and not overthink it," and I stopped fosing aug after pushing on him d1.

I didn't puhs on connor and i haven't been defensive in the way a scum would be.

From your pov specifically and from gerry's pov in your opinion, justdance, what have I done to be or not be TR'd? You did say you tr'd me. Then you retracted it to an extent, but you still tr other people, and you're questioning me on what i've done to be tr'd now which sounds like it's implying I haven't done much to be tr'd. What have I done not to be tr'd? Play outrageously? Because that's less of a scumtell than sonrio's lack of posting, which was already not a scumtell.

Why are YOUR reads inconsistent? Why do you favor certain logic over other logic that's equally valid? Why do you say things like, "impoetic could be mafia but she's still probably town," knowing you're such a great player and that saying those things isn't necessarily protown?
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
i regret asking
citeopmIover 10 years ago
...much more easily than i can see someone actually thinking I'm scum here, at least if you're Gerry or justian666
citeopmIover 10 years ago
gerry tr'd me the past 2 or 3 games but doesn't tr me as much this game. It's true he tr'd me when I was mafia once but he was null on me until later that game and other people didn't tr me as much.

what have I done to make myself a decent lynch target from a townie's perspective? 'Cause I can see how someone could FAKE an fos on me without really thinking it through (mafia)
citeopmIover 10 years ago
^^^^ [mental impairment intensifies] ^^^

I've been mostly transparent about my thought processes and defended most of the people being lynched. I defended sonrio when i could have pushed on him; I defended you when it makes more sense for me as either alignment to push on you; I went after mist instead of aug or n1ed even though she hard tr's me and it'd be super easy for me to just tr her back and as scum i'd be hesitant to push on her because you know. I like her and i like playing with her so it's hard to make myself wanna ml her despite the fact that her towntells are actually indicative of good town play if she's town, whereas others' are mostly ate/"Oh they seem genuine i tr them"/"Oh they reacted well to X"
citeopmIover 10 years ago
justdance666
Impoetic
Ian, I still find your read on me kinda hard to believe. Same w your sonrio fos as opposed to the d1 aug tr
what do you think you've done to deserve a townread
I've been hard tr'd by a bunch of people so either they're faking reads or I am pretty dern towny. I've played in a townier way than i did last game, and I was tr'd all-around then. I've had posts I myself would view as genuine, I know everyone here has seen my play as town and mafia, and my play overall would be absurd for mafia because I've pushed on almost everyone here and given people a chance to omgus (which town often does cuz they can't fathom foses on them), fos me for having inconsistent reads (also done a lot), or jump on a bw since i have so much influence.


in fact if i were maf i'd be using my influence, not wasting it by flipping around and spazzing out all game. And weird logic isn't a scumtell in 9/10 cases; afia's more likely to focus on making their logic look consistent than town. I've generally towntold more than most people here and your tr's tr me for the most part. I'm really transparent pretty often although not always, and I'm a very paranoid person so the fact that my paranoia has been directed at who is scum rather than who scumreads me is in and iof itself a big tt
1
citeopmIover 10 years ago
justdance666
Impoetic
Ian, I still find your read on me kinda hard to believe. Same w your sonrio fos as opposed to the d1 aug tr
what do you think you've done to deserve a townread
I've been hard tr'd by a bunch of people so either they're faking reads or I am pretty dern towny. I've played in a townier way than i did last game, and I was tr'd all-around then. I've had posts I myself would view as genuine, I know everyone here has seen my play as town and mafia, and my play overall would be absurd for mafia because I've pushed on almost everyone here and given people a chance to omgus (which town often does cuz they can't fathom foses on them), fos me for having inconsistent reads (also done a lot), or jump on a bw since i have so much influence.


in fact if i were maf i'd be using my influence, not wasting it by flipping around and spazzing out all game. And weird logic isn't a scumtell in 9/10 cases; afia's more likely to focus on making their logic look consistent than town. I've generally towntold more than most people here and your tr's tr me for the most part. I'm really transparent pretty often although not always, and I'm a very paranoid person so the fact that my paranoia has been directed at who is scum rather than who scumreads me is in and iof itself a big tt
1
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Impoetic
if she thought you were real she wouldn't want to force mafia to kill lol. Also the demeanor of the post.
that too
1
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
it isn't that. it's almost an appeal to me while she's talking about the uncertainty of it in the same post. i wouldn't call it too careless to be mafia but something along those lines
2
citeopmIover 10 years ago
if she thought you were real she wouldn't want to force mafia to kill lol. Also the demeanor of the post.

Asking to be checked is something that happens in ruby mafia.

she might have known you weren't pr though
Gerryover 10 years ago
TR Mist for that is a weak reason as mafia I always say "Cop check me please"
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Impoetic
Ian, I still find your read on me kinda hard to believe. Same w your sonrio fos as opposed to the d1 aug tr
what do you think you've done to deserve a townread
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Impoetic
specifically acting to be checked is the least towny thing about that post
i disagree. most of the post is talking about mechanics. i think that acknowledging me the way she did without the need for justification is more town than mafia
citeopmIover 10 years ago
but it's very possible you're forcing towntells this game to give the same effect by coincidence. Other games the towntells felt less condensed, if that makes sense. I would fos you more if it weren't for my blotchy memory and the fact that I do remember sring you for sorta coasting a couple games and that's 1 part of what has caused me not to tr you so much this game. some1. help. me.
citeopmIover 10 years ago
Gerry
Impoetic
I go back and forth about gerry and mist more than anyone else but that does not necessarily mean they're scum, and iirc I did that about gerry all the other games too
Hey. What was my alignment those other games?
that was my point.
citeopmIover 10 years ago
mist
maybe it is just him trolling actually that im picking up on be he's incredibly "forced" for lack of a better word. maybe i can explain it better later, part of it rn is a gut feeling. i just feel like im watching the same i watched last game and no hate guys but last game i was rolling my eyes pretty much all day 1 while ian was pushing hedger.
was this an rxn test 100% or only some smaller percentage
Gerryover 10 years ago
Impoetic
I go back and forth about gerry and mist more than anyone else but that does not necessarily mean they're scum, and iirc I did that about gerry all the other games too
Hey. What was my alignment those other games?
citeopmIover 10 years ago
mist
PoE/his play has been really awkward/no redeeming aspects of game
loooooool

"no redeeming aspects of his game"
citeopmIover 10 years ago
Ian, I still find your read on me kinda hard to believe. Same w your sonrio fos as opposed to the d1 aug tr