Whales: Surf or Turf?

LeMeJoeover 10 years ago

This is a question that's really been bugging me.

Say I invite you to a surf and turf dinner at my place. For those that don't know, a surf and turf is a dish containing both seafood and meat, typically shellfish and steak. (Thanks Google).

The question then, is this. If I served whale meat at this dinner, which would it be classified as?

BASIC TURF ARGUMENT:

-Whale meat is MEAT, no questioning it. This means it can't be classified as fish.

-Whales are mammals, furthering the argument they shouldn't be compared to our classic defintion of seafood.

-Whale meat tastes like really gamey beef (look it up, I did).

BASIC SURF ARGUMENT:

-Whales live in the ocean, therefore they should be classified as seafood.

-Although whales are mammals, they are clearly thought of as being closer to fish than a cow or something.

I won't give my opinion yet. Do your job, EM. Expand the arguments and debate away.

No hedging your bets.

Poll
Surf or Turf?
Surf50%1
Turf50%1
Goodbarover 10 years ago
whales used to walk on land. turf.
deleteddeletedover 10 years agoedited
surf. whales live in the surf, not on the turf. therefore it's surf.
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Alternatively, don't serve whale meat.
LeMeJoeover 10 years ago
SURFY TURFY BUMP