Town Problems?

Giga13over 10 years ago

Hello everyone, I am Giga13/Giga ( https://epicmafia.com/user/220988 / https://epicmafia.com/user/144777 ). If you're having trouble as town, especially after really dicey, in-your-face, poorly-handled matches, you might wonder "why does the town blow up so much? Is it my fault? Could I have done something different? What can I do to improve?"

Aside from things such as reading players and things of that nature, there are three super simple things that ANY town can do to increase their win chances.

So the question is, how do we avoid these silly outcomes? How do we avoid caps-lock raging, words-a-flailing, idiotic scenarios that usually result in needless massclaims day 1 and town losses not too long after?

STICK TO THE FUNDAMENTALS. DON'T TRY TO BE CUTE OR FANCY.

  1. Do not roleswap unless you know the people you are swapping with are clear. Too often people roleswap uselessly, needlessly, and as a result, important roles that need to be protected are outted and the town ends up floundering into a loss because they don't know what to do or how to play.

  2. Do not shout things like "ORACLE CLAIMS" or "DOCTOR CLAIMS" unless you ONE HUNDRED PERCENT KNOW WHAT IS STATISTICALLY AND MECHANICALLY OPTIMAL FOR THE SITUATION. Figure out what is optimal for the situation and ask/make sure of it and make sure people AGREE before telling someone to claim or before you claim yourself. Mafia might lie to you, so if there's any doubt, take the time to try and figure out what's best yourself and then discuss what you think is the best course of action. It could take some time, but it 's worth it as you really only have to do it a few times with different players before they all understand what the best course of action is given a situation in future games--and it could very well be the difference between winning a game or losing a game. Don't say you're right unless you KNOW you're right. Also, DON'T GET INTO ARGUMENTS over these things. Just discuss it calmly in order to prevent or before someone just goes nuts and claims or does something that is irreversible.

  3. DO NOT do stupid tests or things like naked tests, faking a report, or fakeclaiming in general. Ask yourself: "How do these help the town?" The answer is: They rarely ever do. These hardly ever work, and sometimes they cause less experienced players to claim their role to avoid being voted at rapid speeds right away, which automatically puts town at a HUGE disadvantage, especially if they are a power role that is meant to be hidden. I've played over 2000 games with oracles in the setup and I will tell you right now that I have seen a naked test work TWO TIMES in TWO THOUSAND + GAMES. Do the math. That's a 0.1% success rate. It's useless. Don't do it.

DISOBEYING THESE THINGS GIVE MAFIA AN ADVANTAGE. THEY ALREADY HAVE AN ADVANTAGE, YOU DON'T WANT TO GIVE THEM EVEN MORE OF AN UPPER HAND. STICK TO THE FUNDAMENTALS.

Following these three simple, SIMPLE things will improve your chances of winning as town. These are three simple things that once were the norm in games, but seem to have somehow been lost in a lot of today's gameplay.

Thank you for reading, and happy playing! I can answer some basic questions if you have any, just post below.

SirSlickover 10 years ago
the amount of times i've been lynched as town for "bad rxns" when someone just plonks a vote on me is ridiculously high
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
A big part of being a good town is being able to scum hunt and a big part of scum hunting is getting genuine reactions from others and the best way of getting reactions from someone is voting someone else and seeing how that person reacts to it. at first I found this out by myself but after seeing pranay say the same thing I was sure that this method works and works really well.
Giga13over 10 years ago
RhinoSoreAss
Everyone should read this
Thank you for your feedback!
deleteddeletedover 10 years agoedited
Mafia is in fact at a disadvantage upon any game-start.
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
I can put my math to use here. Just give us 30 minutes and this strat will work so well.
DeadmanWonderlandover 10 years ago
Just as i read this i played a game where gs fakeclaimed doc...sigh
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Everyone should read this
Giga13over 10 years agoedited
MMCombat
Following common protocols is very important when it comes to winning the game. Thanks Giga for clarifying this
xela
thanks giga
Glad it helped
xelaover 10 years ago
thanks giga
1
MMCombatover 10 years ago
Following common protocols is very important when it comes to winning the game. Thanks Giga for clarifying this
1
Giga13over 10 years ago
Devante
the naked test point is false, as it can be used to see how people in the town react to you naked testing
There are better ways of doing this such as reaction fosing and reaction voting (without mechanical basis such as a naked player or faking that a player is naked). Often times it stalls early game development and many artificial tells and reactions can come from this for sure. Thank you for your feedback
ArianaGrandeover 10 years ago
i read none of that

but i agree
1
Devanteover 10 years ago
the naked test point is false, as it can be used to see how people in the town react to you naked testing
1
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
i have 99 problems and 98 of them stem from living in a meth town
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
If you got town problems I feel bad for ya son, I got 99 problems, but living in a meth town ain't one.
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
if youre having town problems move to a city
1
Giga13over 10 years ago
voluntaryloser
DO NOT do stupid tests or things like naked tests or fakeclaiming. Ask yourself: "How do these help the town?" The answer is: They rarely ever do. These hardly ever work
you should clarify that this doesn't include faking your report as an investigative role
I like this point. Thank you for your feedback, added
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
DO NOT do stupid tests or things like naked tests or fakeclaiming. Ask yourself: "How do these help the town?" The answer is: They rarely ever do. These hardly ever work
you should clarify that this doesn't include faking your report as an investigative role
1
Giga13over 10 years ago
Thank you for your feedback
Iukeover 10 years ago
#2 is the only really factual one here. A majority of those games you played didn't involve naked tests, so your assumption on the success rate is horribly inaccurate. It's closer to 1-2%, which is still awful though.

#1 smells like salt.
YukiOkamiover 10 years ago
Support the campaign.
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
make mafia great again.
1
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
ban the most popular setup yes
deleteddeletedover 10 years ago
Tisguyisawesome
Ban fancy pants.
YukiOkamiover 10 years ago
Please blacklist fancy pants indeed.