Grim's Paradox

deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
It's not supposed to be BV, it's supposed to be something fun and new. It probably does lean towards town, but I doubt it leans that way more than 5%
Strideralmost 11 years ago
Grim
I don't think it's more than 5% townsided, although it probably does lean towards town
a) yes it will be
b) 5% itself is too much
Strideralmost 11 years ago
it's more townsided than cno/cns and wwtw that's for sure

i agree that fj2 and wwtw are pretty bad though
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
I don't think it's more than 5% townsided, although it probably does lean towards town
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Felons
if you keep the setup how it currently is it's going to be a bad setup and a town pointfarm.
It's definitely not worse than FJ2, Cry N Spy, or WWTW. It's not supposed to be the next BV
Strideralmost 11 years ago
it's town sided as balls is the point i'm making, stupid
Felonsalmost 11 years ago
if you keep the setup how it currently is it's going to be a bad setup and a town pointfarm.
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
If you lynch mafia day one in STBS and you don't suck you tend to win about 80% of the time
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Yeah, if mafia gets lynched day one mafia's odds are lowered significantly. What's your point?
Strideralmost 11 years agoedited
if hooker is lynched day 1, high chance of town autowin
if don is lynched day 1, there's still a pretty significant chance of town autowin
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
That's like saying "If you lynch wrong twice its basically game over"
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Strider
if don OTs to hooker it's basically game over
1. That's a choice Don would make. Don isn't obligated to OT

2. While OTing to hooker is the worst possible thing that can happen to mafia, it does not by any means end the game.
Strideralmost 11 years ago
if don OTs to hooker it's basically game over
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Strider
dawn start is fundamentally better even if you like mafia not knowing each other
I disagree, and think dawn start would scum side it.
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
If don OTs to hooker off of a blue and then hits detective and survives one lynch, its still 3 way 1 clear.
Strideralmost 11 years ago
dawn start is fundamentally better even if you like mafia not knowing each other
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years agoedited
Felons
mafia not knowing each other in a setup with 2 mafia and day start is pretty stupid and unfair to mafia, it's like you're trying your hardest to make a town pointfarm.
Except it's really not! Don determines which town is lynched if at all, and there's a hooker!
Felonsalmost 11 years ago
mafia not knowing each other in a setup with 2 mafia and day start is pretty stupid and unfair to mafia, it's like you're trying your hardest to make a town pointfarm.
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Top setup tier
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Giga13
You didn't try dawnstart
I really like mafia not knowing each other. OTing creates a clear and you might hit your partner, but if you have a strong PR read the temptation might be too much
Giga13almost 11 years ago
You didn't try dawnstart
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
50/50 after 4 games definitely 100% balanced comp it
Orlyalmost 11 years ago
ehhhh ok
deleteddeletedalmost 11 years ago
Orly
im not sure i understand what Don's role descrip says. it cant OT if the lynch is on mafia? so then all it does is OT onto other towns if town is being lynched? isnt that like, creating a clear?
Yeah, therein lies the risk
Orlyalmost 11 years ago
im not sure i understand what Don's role descrip says. it cant OT if the lynch is on mafia? so then all it does is OT onto other towns if town is being lynched? isnt that like, creating a clear?