Epicmafia

Graveyard no cheating edition

deleteddeletedabout 11 years ago

We all know when your dead your able to see night/day actions and mafia or guns and whispers

What if we removed this in ranked your not able to see night/day actions you cannot see whispers(unless the leak) so poeple cant alt anymore unless Alt a is on town and Alt b is on mafia. Then alt A will still able to out mafia but this will decrease cheating by a high percentage

Poll

Should those graveyard features removed?

Not at all58%14

Only comp33%8

Only ranked4%1

Only Ranked and Comp4%1

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years ago

Giga13

AdrenalineMime
Giga13
AdrenalineMime
you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then
Uh, no
?
Are you suggesting we should let random people not in game spectate ranked games from a graveyard perspective?

If not, sorry

from decreased gy perspective (as in OP), yes

JeffreyAaronabout 11 years ago

I oppose this. GY is one very redeeming point of this site when at times it can be hard.

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

if you're going to change anything about ranked games, make it so if u leave a ranked game after you die you're able to rejoin to spectate it.

i can't tell u how many times i got lynched as town and rage sui'd only to wonder what the town was doing the following days - only to realize i sui'd and can't go back till the end of the game :(

Giga13about 11 years ago

AdrenalineMime

Giga13
AdrenalineMime
you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then
Uh, no
?

Are you suggesting we should let random people not in game spectate ranked games from a graveyard perspective?

If not, sorry

Honeybadger604about 11 years ago

Giga13

Don't do this. It will only make it harder for us to determine if users are cheating or not and make graveyards not entertaining at all.

exactly

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years ago

Giga13

AdrenalineMime
you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then
Uh, no

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Giga13about 11 years ago

AdrenalineMime

you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then

Uh, no

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years agoedited

you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then

deleteddeletedabout 11 years ago

idk, i can see it being fun trying to figure out who the mafia is from the graveyard but i guess you're probably right that it's a loss.

Giga13about 11 years agoedited

Don't do this. It will only make it harder for us to determine if users are cheating or not and make graveyards not entertaining at all.

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years ago

if it's only hiding roles and not speech then whatever fine

deleteddeletedabout 11 years ago

it'd obviously reduce the impact of cheating, but graveyard vision is also probably one of the most amusing/educational facets of this game

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

I don't even play mafia anymore and this idea is hurting my spirit

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

mist

Yeah I really don't see this making much of a difference to be honest but it could be worth a shot?

It's really not.

elfireabout 11 years ago

DO IT LUCID

deleteddeletedabout 11 years ago

Yeah I really don't see this making much of a difference to be honest but it could be worth a shot?

deleteddeletedabout 11 years ago

Sanctify

"Let's punish the masses because of the
few"

this is correct. graveyard vision owns, lucid.

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years ago

people that cheat by sharing roles from gy are already contacting players out-of-game, meaning those people can still cheat via rolesharing, information sharing, etc.
so freqeuncy will not decrease

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

Don't, lucid........

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

"Let's punish the masses because of the few"

adminabout 11 years ago

i can build this

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

Sanctify

1039

This is the amount of times this stupid idea has even suggested and shot down.

AdrenalineMimeabout 11 years agoedited

WolfODonnellz

AdrenalineMime
i dont think this will decrease cheating by a high percentage but whatever
But it does decrease it quite a bit because you know all mafia prs in night or day etc

that only reduces the in-game impact of cheating [by a large percent], not its frequency.

Sanctifyabout 11 years ago

1039