Can someone explain

RelicScattergunover 11 years ago

I'm relatively new, and I took a break a long time after signing up. I've been playing a lot the past few days, and I was wondering if an experienced mafia player could tell me why my partner said I came off as "extremely scummy" in this game:

https://epicmafia.com/game/3821102/review

RelicScattergunover 11 years ago
Hi guys!

I actually reviewed some games from recent competitive rounds, and I noticed I actually didn't do as bad as I guess we both thought d1. I noticed I tend to say more in one sentence than breaking it up like more competitive towntellers do. I also need much more practice making foses and reading people.

My real mistake imho was in d2, I should've fought for doc and tried to convince the inno with a hammer or something.

Thank you all for your feedback!
1
Wizardryover 11 years ago
he has a bronze trophy but i guess he cheated for it
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
there's nothing that sticks out really it's just that in the final 3 you went up against a doc-save and the cop's inno, neither of which can be argued as scum especially in a setup where scum puts themselves at a disadvantage if they no-kill the first night
1
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
Germatron
probably because you tried to say doc save isnt clear. mafia has no reason to nk n1 and doc save is pretty much clear and you disagreeing is scummy.

Also, a good amount of filler and you kind of sounded fake
Ignore this guy, he has no trophies. I have a trophy and I say he's wrong.
2
Wizardryover 11 years ago
doc save isn't clear there. if you think stating facts to correct statements is scummy then you're stupid.
1
deleteddeletedover 11 years ago
probably because you tried to say doc save isnt clear. mafia has no reason to nk n1 and doc save is pretty much clear and you disagreeing is scummy.

Also, a good amount of filler and you kind of sounded fake
Wizardryover 11 years ago
you were mafia, mafia are supposed to lose and if they don't then the town sucked
justrecover 11 years ago
You did fine day one from what I can see
1
Jillover 11 years ago
Ur first mistake was playing fancy pants
1