post here

Anthonyalmost 12 years ago

For my humble opinion on your mafia play. If I haven't played with you, ill quote your post with a filler until I do. Will do in a few hours

Edit: people who I have not played with/don't know who they are so I will get to them if I play with them:

Nice

Hobbylobby

Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Will do the rest later
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
soda17
anythong
I used to think you were really irritating to play with since you'd afk all the time. In fact, I'd actually dodge you all the time. Then you started running and I realized that when you care, you're a really good player. Sometimes you're easy to read and sometimes you're difficult, which makes you unpredictable. You do a good job of saccing yourself to get the misslynch off, which is a key component of being mafia. You sometimes get fooled by "obvious scum", but you can POE the rest of the town to catch those scum fast which makes you win a lot of games.
1
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
OK
gistofeverythingalmost 12 years ago
So do me
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Hiya Anthony
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Weird, where did my post go?

Anyways, go ahead.
soda17almost 12 years ago
anythong
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Shivv
Watup
You're one of the best players currently playing. To be honest, I thought you only won your first two trophies because of abc, and thought your winrate was only because of reverse, but when I came back from being unbanned, I realized why you had 3 more trophies, and a HOF winrate account. I think sometimes you are overconfident which leads you to losing games, but when you're playing to win, you're extremely hard to beat. You play virtually the same as any role and you have accurate reads regardless of alignment.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
Watup
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
lolwot
hello
Ok, you are actually a really underrated and good player. I think your only issue is you sometimes tunnel too much, and occasionally blame someone if they react to your tunnel in a way you don't like. Usually though, you have really accurate reads and are a difficult read.
deleteddeletedalmost 12 years ago
hello
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
SystemOverload
I'm ready
Ahhh this should be fun. Systemoverload, master of choking. You pretty much already know my opinion of you, but I'll say it anyway. Your biggest issue, which unfortunately is a big one, is you have a very hard time with finding balance. You are either underconfident, or overconfident. You're either overreact, or under-react. You sometimes try too hard to be someone you're not, which comes off as forced. When it comes to reads and your confidence is ballanced, you're borderline impeccable. You're almost never wrong. This is why you won gold round 75, and why you start off every round extremely well. When you have nothing to lose, you have the best reads and a really well developed scumgame.
Edarkalmost 12 years ago
I dont dislike you anthony, maybe u fell victim to one of my clever ruses :^)
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Edark
do it NOW
I have no idea why you dislike me since I feel like you and I would get along great if we talked, but I digress. To be quite honest, I used to think you were really bad because all you'd do is afk and random vote. When you actually started trying, I realized that despite everyone saying you are really good, you're still underrated because you're better than everyone says you are. You're almost impossible for me to read; when you're town I think your scum until I realize I can't find a single reason to scumread you, and when you're scum I think you're town. I think your biggest issue is you let your emotions get the better of you when you don't care that much, which makes you grudge in certain situations. When you're town, your reads are usually really good, especially with newer players. You can POE better than most people on the site.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
hedger
meow
You're another easy read for me. When you're town though, you will almost never get lynched. You also know how to ATE yourself out of a lynch if your scum, which can come in handy. When it comes to your town game, you almost always win 3way lylo's because everyone will townread you, and you hammer accurately 90% of the time. Your also very good at CC battles, regardless of alignment.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Rawrarrior
posting for an opinion
I remember being extremely impressed with your play. You actually carried me a lot when I was dead during my run. I will say that you are unfortunately a pretty easy read. I know that hypocritical since I'm one of the easiest reads on the site, but I think you try to hard as scum (on your tryhard account) and it costs you games. When it comes to scumhunting, you get into the heads of the people you're analyzing instead of just reading what they are saying, which is the most important and hardest thing to do when scumhunting and you do it extremely well.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Love
ok hello
Honestly I don't remember playing with you at all, I just remember you selfdeleting after I gave you a harassment violation which I still feel bad about; hopefully everything is ok now, and you didn't selfdelete because of me. Based on your personality and what I know about you, I think you'd have a really really really good scumgame.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Reverend
yes hello anthony
Ignoring the Jericho post because it's a repeat I think. You're one of the better players out there. I don't know how or why, but you went from one of the easiest reads to the most difficult reads overnight, and I'm 100% sure I didn't teach you how to do that. Your biggest issue I think is you are usually passive in games, and I feel as if you don't trust yourself or your reads enough, which is a shame because you're usually right, and you don't get sheeped because of it. However like I said, your reads are very accurate and you're a pain in the to read.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
gennehfarrxD
thimble
We actually haven't played much together :[. From what I remember though, you are a pretty good scumhunter and a decently difficult read. I think your main issue is that you tend to rely on meta a little too much, which can sometimes bite you in the a*s. However, your reads because of meta are almost always accurate and win you a lot of games. When you don't use meta, you still scumhunt pretty well.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
KillHimNotMe
rate me
The one game I remember playing with you was when you basically just sheeped crypto, so I don't really know how good you are. However, your posting is great and your post about your dog howling while you played piano because of Pranay made me laugh really f*cking hard.
Anthonyalmost 12 years ago
Goodbar
himble dimble jack be nimble
I was hoping you'd post. Quite honestly, I think you're easily one of the best players on the site. That being said, I think sometimes your judgement is clouded because you tend to give people the benefit of the doubt when sometimes they don't deserve it. This makes you susceptible to being wifomed sometimes easily. Otherwise, you have extremely accurate reads and it's usually very difficult to differentiate your town and scumgame.
SystemOverloadalmost 12 years ago
I'm ready
Edarkalmost 12 years ago
do it NOW
hedgeralmost 12 years ago
meow
Echoalmost 12 years ago
posting for an opinion