wait. you can start a game with consigs as the only mafia? i always assumed that would bug the setup. interesting idea, but loudmouth too OP with 3 PRs imo
mechanics of the civilian make the role hard to fit into the conventional setup format without making the game entirely luck based or swingy.
the only solution to this currently seems to be populating the entire town with them.
eg. if you put 1 civ in a setup, the entire setup revolves around protecting the civ.
if you have 2, it becomes a luckbased game with no actual point.
if you have 3 or 4 (say you want it to be the blue replacement) mafia is near guaranteed a win after 1 mislynch on a mislynch setup, and the role is useless entirely if you didnt have a mislynch to start with.
if you have 5+ the setup becomes viable, but you have no room for PRS
suggested fix: make the mafia win mechanic activate when all civs are dead.
this way you can have 2-4 in a setup, instead of essentially being forced to have 1 or 5+
