>playing sandbox
>roll this role
>so mad
>day 2 lylo with tree
>
>they can force nl
>remember i'm judge
>my time to shine
>lynch wrong

If it was about three votes, then it would be like a governor. This role sucks

Needs to be at least 3 votes to be somewhat useful. Or a percentage.

shit role is shit

foolish role. :D

im gay

what the hell this role isn't bad....you are all just dumb bitches who don't know how to win as this role.....get real

change the role to "Upon hammering, the person voted by the judge will be lynched if it is also currently voted by someone else." Real judge must hold the hammer to death. http://www.epicmafia.com/topic/43053

yay! go judge! welcome back

Welcome back, Judge!

Oh nice, it changed.

change the role to.
Vote counts as two during the day.
sided with the village.
Also make the mafia judge role so that it can be counter claimed if both are in the same setup. http://www.epicmafia.com/role/2684

How about we change the role description to this:

As long as she is alive, if a person is lynched by one vote, that person may appeal.

In an appeal, the judge decides whether or not to lynch that person.

If the judge lynches him, he dies.

If the judge does not lynch him, he lives, but if the town lynches him again, he may not appeal.

People in jail may also appeal if the jailer is about to kill him.

In this situation, if the judge does not lynch a person, he lives, but if he's thrown back into jail and the jailer tries to kill him again, he dies.

Sided with the town.

I just think the judge is a crappy role, so either use this or remove it.

Why not just make this a town sided Politician? A villager with a vote that counts twice. This would ofcourse lead into what everyone expects which would be mafia with the same ability.

-170 points... shouldn't this role be removed?

lolthisroleissopointless

It should have a vote if it doesn't hammer and have two if it hammers, it would balance it out, politician gets two period if it votes, why can't judge have 2 IF it votes last?

Considering the role has been removed, perhaps this page should be too...

because the role is worse than villager lol.

why the hell is this role gone yet we can still use cthulu?

The best role

Should have modeled it after Judge Mathis, aka the best Judge.

FEMALE VILLAGER

Makes me wonder why it hasn't been removed yet.

increase it to two votes.