Then in the situation in the future, I suggest you kill the guilty. Town was completely ruined by the Throw. And if he'd have got the guilty correct, then I'd've still given him Gamethrowing, just for random-guiltying.

I'm sorry if that seems harsh, but I can't in good conscience not refund this.

I'd like to keep the win. We should have just killed shuya, but still. He FoS'd shuya, and if shuya had been scum (gf or otherwise) there was no way it would get reported. He basically turned it into a "win or tie" situation for town if this gets refunded.