Not only that. Purr was the only clear person on day 1. If clear tells you with 100% certainty that someone is mafia, even for reasons he chooses to not out, then why wouldn't town listen to him?

Purr, as confirmed town (clear for reasons explained already), guaranteed to the town that Alpha was mafia, but town chose not to listen to her.

index alpha was never an option because purr never claimed tracker. he was an option to purr and purr only

It was guaranteed that BG was alive that game. The only one possible way for Alpha to be have a hope of avoiding a lynch if everyone understood is this one scenario:
(1) Purr is actual BG.
(2) Janitor and vanilla mafia chose to kill on night 1, and disguiser chose not to kill, while visiting Purr on night 1 to fake bodyguard.

Alpha could ONLY have mafia visiting town, so from his POV, Purr was clear. From Purr's POV, Alpha was confirmed mafia. Therefore, Alpha should have been the only option for a d1 lynch.

"this is where you're wrong. it doesn't make alpha maf. it makes his report mafia." What are you suggesting? That the janitor and nilla both chose to kill, while the guiser NK'd and faked a visit? If "Alpha's report is mafia," it could only be a NKing disguiser visiting someone to fake BG, otherwise the only way it could be a guilty is if it was a "double visit," as PURRNICIOUS HERSELF said at the end of day 1. It means she was considering all of these possibilities, and playing the fake claim strategically. This is definitely not an instance of gamethrowing, because Purrnicious thinking this way makes it obvious it was strategy, not ameans to purposefully lose.

Why did you guys lynch Sarynade? Purr was doing a pro play as tracker. Alpha, the tracker claim (maf) said BG visited Purr. Purr claimed BG and was unccd, making the Alpha maf<<<< this is where you're wrong. it doesn't make alpha maf. it makes his report mafia.

I think if you and I did this play kittenz, neither of us would get lynched and mafia would be demolished~

Dead srs

lol index r u joking?

Props to Purr for doing something so amazing. I'm going to try this as tracker.

This would also cause mafia to shoot Purr (the BG claim) after Alpha got lynched, and Sary would be able to save Purr. Mafia wouldn't know what hit them.

Why did you guys lynch Sarynade? Purr was doing a pro play as tracker. Alpha, the tracker claim (maf) said BG visited Purr. Purr claimed BG and was unccd, making the Alpha maf. Sarynade also knew Alpha was fake because the visit was wrong, so Sarynade did not cc Purr for BG. This AMAZING play went totally over all your heads. It may have been accidental on Purr/Sary's parts, but the claims they made were PERFECT.

as you can see i was in the middle of attemptin to explain the possibility of tracker janned at the end, instead everyone voted on me so quickly. You should never assume especially with an uncced tracker that the report is true.

you should have claimed bg before being lynched.

you are a dumbass, supposed tracker faked a report on me and real tracker cced me, if you asshats listened to me like i said without fishin for my role and nled ON MYLO this wouldnt have happened tyvm